/

/

The Great Roof, Bluff Knoll

First Ascents

The Great Roof, Bluff Knoll

Started by Logan

·

·

31 replies

Archived thread

Replies are closed. Some details, such as access rules and gate codes, may be out of date.

Logan - 5 Nov 2007

I freed the long standing project 'The Great Roof' at Bluff Knoll yesterday. Started up Coercion then a couple of pitches up a face trending right to the Ladies Changroom ledge, through the roof then easy to the top.

I think the climbing through the roof warrants a solid 26 but this isnt to be taken lightly. It also deserves an R and X grade as it has a large run out (8-10m) off the anchor on suspect rock that will result in a trip to the hospital/morgue if a hold breaks and you fall. The gear through the roof is also the old aid bolts and a rusty pin and coroded nut. The route is amazingly exposed and i think it may feel harder than 26 purely because of how much you over grip on the holds due to nervousness.

So in conclusion its a not to be taken lightly 26 R X.

Have fun playing on this!

Rob vanhaeften got photos so they may turn up somewhere. Owen Davis was also on the ascent.


Logan - 5 Nov 2007

Also thanks to Dan from Paddy Pallin for providing support and driving us three sleepy climbers home!!


George - 5 Nov 2007

Nice work Logan, great to hear it finally went down!.


Richard W - 5 Nov 2007

Superb work guys. Don't think too many others will be "playing" on that one!


Ross Weiter - 5 Nov 2007

Wow, awesome. I wish I had the guns&guts to do that.....

A comment on the grading. The route would be graded 26R if you think that a credible fall would most likely cause non-life threatening injuries (sprained ankle, broken hip/leg/achilles....). It would be graded 26X if you think that a credible fall would cause life threatening injuries.

i.e. R is not "runout" but "risky", X is "extremely risky"....there can be very run out routes with no risk because you will not hit anything (ground, ledge...) ie Mt Cuthbert. That's how the sustem is mean to work as far as I can tell....I imported it from the US where I climbed for a few months; into the Perth guide and that's the way it is used there. The yanks also sometimes say 5.11R/X if they cannot decide whether the fall would be deadly but that is being a bit too fine I think....

It recognises the mental dimension of climbing (like the UK E- system), which the traditional Aus Ewbank system does not.

Anyway, blah, blah.....


Logan - 5 Nov 2007

Thanks for the clarification Ross. Its possible to really do yourself over if you do fall but you may get away with just some busted legs or you may be lucky and be alright (unlikely). The fact is if you do do something even minor you are then stuck half way up Bluff Knoll. I think an R/X grade is apropriate.


Toc - 5 Nov 2007

Cool Logan,

Along with everyone else, I'm in awe.

Toc.


Jeff M - 5 Nov 2007

Now I am just curious why you wrote this the other day? You a bit worried someone else may have snatched your glory?

Logan, 1 Nov 2007

I heard the great roof sucked and was a complete waste of time. Its not worthy of the trip down. Go climb somewhere good like churchmans brook. I wouldnt rush to the roof


Dinah Pantic - 6 Nov 2007

I agree, absolutely awesome. Well done Logan, it's good to hear your climbing so going so strong.


Logan - 6 Nov 2007

Jeff M,

If you knew my views on Churchmans Brook you would have seen the sarcasm in that meassage straight away :)


Jeff M - 6 Nov 2007

Logan

No I can see the sarcasm clearly, but can also see you steering the punter (space cadet though he may have been) away from a line you wanted the ffa on.

I thought this forum was to promote climbing and climbers?


Logan - 6 Nov 2007

Youd think a comment like that as obviously sarcastic as it was would spur a punter on. Do you not agree?


Toc - 7 Nov 2007

I won't be doing a second ascent and I will have a huge amount of respect for anyone who does. There won't be many takers I'm guessing.

Anyway Churchman's is great if you can stop your car from being broken into.

Cheers,

Toc.


ed nepia - 7 Nov 2007

steering others away from a coveted first ascent is a time honoured art form and should be widely encouraged... gotta keep people guessing eh..


Owen - 7 Nov 2007

anyone facile enough to be tricked by the churchies comment would die on the roof anyway, so the comment may have saved a life no?


Jeff M - 7 Nov 2007

oh right so you were using sarcasm to create a reverse psycological effect then? Here's me thinking that you were just trying to mislead someone from the roof project when really you were using a fantastic old technique to get Idratherbejambing over to give you a bit of a run to see who got it first, wow you are deep


Jeff M - 8 Nov 2007

Owen are you saying that if someone is easily influenced or does not have the intelligence to see through a ruse that they will not be a strong climber?


Owen - 8 Nov 2007

nope... but a meathead of that class would almost certainly take a wrong turn up there and end up in a world of hurt


mike - 8 Nov 2007

play nice kids or you wont get any sliced oranges for little-lunch


Logan - 8 Nov 2007

Jeff M,

Wow, you really seem to have some kind of chip on your shoulder. You need to see whats important here in that there is an awsome route for people to aspire to doing. It seems like you just want to argue a pointless point and stir up the pot. You should try climbing sometime to help you chill out.


ed nepia - 8 Nov 2007

hahahahaha this is funny! bit of light relief after venting about the booking systems


Kris - 8 Nov 2007

Hey Logan,

Top effort mate! Should i be lucky enough in this life time to even do the first move of this climb, do i book through you or do i have to tell DEC??

Mint


Toc - 8 Nov 2007

At the moment there is a certain amount of sanity in the Stirlings. You don't book, but there is, (or was), a book you could sign into just to let DEC know who was up there, just in case you didn't come back. (The idea was you signed out as well). It wasn't a requirement, just a good idea, left over from the days of yore.


Logan - 8 Nov 2007

The book is still there. In that sort of environment it is a good idea to say what your plans are in case you get into trouble. Just remember to sign out!


Toc - 8 Nov 2007

Thanks Logan.

A system that works, doesn't include "booking", let's everybody know what's going on and is polite to all parties.

The problem with the quarries isn't how the department needs to deal with climbers, but how the department needs to deal with commercial groups.

For those who want to know I'm definitely supporting Ross being on the committee next year, even this year if he has time.


Dinah - 8 Nov 2007

I log on regularly to the CAWA web site just to see what is happening down there amongest the pea gravel and spiky trees. Gives me a giggle to read whats the goss in the Perth climbing scene and sometimes it's even bloody hilarious. Just like this tagential thread on psychological climbing warfare. Logan you've made your mark on one of the best spots in the world that's what counts. Choice mate.


Nick - 13 Nov 2007

legend!


Brian - 13 Nov 2007

Thanks Nick,

But i think Logan should get the applause!


Owen - 31 Mar 2008

Regretably I broke a fairly important hold of one of the hard moves on the roof yesterday. It will still go, but probably a grade or so harder.

Very sorry about that!


Logan - 31 Mar 2008

Looks like another trip down to do it again! Its all training eh? At least a hold hasnt broken on the low down runout.... yet!


owen - 31 Mar 2008

heh give me a few weeks or so...i'm a bit over it right now.

you were right - walking up the creek is much better than the old tourist track


jobro - 10 May 2010

yo

very curious about the nature of this route, but mostly the run out bit off the anchors...

how difficult is the climbing to the first bit of gear? I can handle run out and death defying as long as I'm not simultaneously trying too hard :)

chur

ps - has it been climbed since the broken hold?

Keep climbing with us

Keep climbing with us

Keep climbing with us