/

/

SW Guide - climbing grade and stars

Climbing Talk

SW Guide - climbing grade and stars

Started by Krish

·

·

20 replies

Archived thread

Replies are closed. Some details, such as access rules and gate codes, may be out of date.

Krish - 23 Mar 2015

While gathering route info for the new SW Guide a few people have commented on grades and star allocations. Some indicate entire areas are either over or under graded, and similar have been made regarding stars. I do not proposed to regrade/star entire areas, but am keen to hear views on individual climbs. As a reminder this guide will include Welly Dam, Castle Rock, Smiths Beach, Moses Rocks, Willyabrup, Gracetown, Wallcliffe, Bob's Hollow & Cosy Corner. So any comments...


Chris - 24 Mar 2015

I was on Be Free at Wallcliffe the other day. That should be a 3-star crag-classic.


Remi - 24 Mar 2015

Ok, let's get the ball rolling and give a hand to Krish:

WALLCLIFFE:
1. I'm Too Sexy for my Python: 23 instead of 24 - also deserves 3 stars instead of 2 IMHO
2. Fun, Love And Joy: 23 instead of 24
3. Banana Arma Rama: 22 instead of 24
4. Kyle (to the Lower Off): 21 instead of 23

BOBS:
5. Elongate: 23 instead of 22 (a few holds have been broken since FA)
6. Puk Puk Sen: 19 instead of 20
7. The route going left of the Fin (finishing at the Lower Offs): 21 instead of 17
8. Hollow Promises: 24 instead of 25
9. Toy Shopping: 25 instead of 26

WILLYABRUP:
10. Inner Space: refer to: https://www.climberswa.asn.au/topic/inner-space-at-willys/
11. Totally Awesome: 2 stars instead of 3
12. Top Gear: 1 star instead of 2
13. Booze Bus: no stars instead of 1
14. Hope: 2 stars instead of 1 (coz everyone does it, it must be good ;-))
15. Handjob: 1 star
16. Rape And Pillage: 2 stars instead of 3 (poor rock quality and marred by the aid start)

Remi


Ryan - 25 Mar 2015

I would have to agree with Remi on pretty much all points, Wallcliffe in particular. As for Willys, I personally rate totally Awesome and think the 3 stars deserved, however take one away from One for the Road for being in consistent. Hope definitely rates two stars, maybe even three. I've only been on the route to the left of Hope once but bugger me if I could work out the crux, definitely felt harder than 21 but I may have just missed the sequence.

Also, Wellington Dam and Smiths Beach Rocks always feel like your getting sand bagged on nearly every route, anyone else feel the same?


B - 25 Mar 2015

BOBS:
7. The route going left of the Fin (finishing at the Lower Offs): 21 instead of 17

Isn't this route Thyeses’ Feast?
https://www.climberswa.asn.au/topic/between-fin-and-black-lung-bobs/

Rebolted in 2007
http://www.chockstone.org/Rebolting/RoutesWA.asp

IMHO, Grade is probably 21 as per the rebolting notes.


Eric F - 25 Mar 2015

WALLCLIFFE
I agree with Remi on all grade changes other than my notes have banana arma rama as a 23

BOBS
Again mostly agree with Remi other than:
Elongate maybe because I am tall it felt more like a pretty stiff 22 (after the holds fell off)
Hollow promises - no real grade 25 crux but just long and pumpy from memory, but not sure if it should go to 24 (Revenge of the Luftwaffe currently graded 24 was easier than HP)

Eric


Neil - 26 Mar 2015

Some old info and discussion here:
https://www.climberswa.asn.au/topic/wa-climbs-tick-list/

and here:
https://www.climberswa.asn.au/topic/grading-the-climb/


Neil - 26 Mar 2015

My 2 cents worth:

WALLCLIFFE:
1. I’m Too Sexy for my Python: 23
2. Fun, Love And Joy: 23
3. Banana Arma Rama: can't remember
4. Kyle (to the Lower Off): 21

BOBS:
5. Elongate: 22 and I did the FA with Kate.
6. Puk Puk Sen: 20
7. The route going left of the Fin (finishing at the Lower Offs): 21
8. Hollow Promises: 25. but soft. not unreasonable compared to similar style routes in the blue mountains and overseas. also very style dependant. if you have good endurance it's a hike.
9. Toy Shopping: 25 or 26 arguable. Once again; compared to similar style routes in the blue mountains and overseas.
10. ROTL: 24 but soft. crux was grabbing the spikey hold at the end i seem to recall.

I think in general for WA climbers, a limestone overhanging sport 24/25/26 is going to feel soft compared to the granite equivalent. For a fair comparison overhanging limestone needs to be benchmarked against similar styled routes. NOT indoor routes either.

For example, one for the road at Willies seems about 16 to me. But I know a few tricks and have done it almost every-time I visit the crag. Doesn't mean it's not 19 though.

Also, how many people know about the knee scum just prior to the crux on Hollow Promises that you can almost go handsfree on ?

Anyway, just an opinion. :-)


Krish - 26 Mar 2015

So from a trad climbers perspective and looking also at some of the lesser visited areas here is my list regarding stars:

Moses:
Hathersage - one star
Mini Thor - one star
Cornish Nasty - one star
Victor and His Boa Constrictor - one star
Wheely Things - two stars
Fat Slags - three stars
Hands Up - one star
A Wet Dream on Elm Street - one star
Freddy Kruger’s Claw - one star

Willyabrup - Main Areas:
Rockfish Dreaming - drop to one star
Top Gear - drop to no stars
One For The Road - drop to two stars
The Booze Bus - drop to no stars
Sinuosity - drop to no stars
Percy Pigsville - drop to no stars
Golden Buttress - three stars
Golden Buttress Direct - drop to no stars
Glory - one star
Hope - three stars
Charity - no stars (agree the crux is very hard, as with Faith)
Heavy Metal - drop to two stars
Washed Up Punks - three stars
Rape and Pillage - drop to two stars
Escape Hatch - no stars
Welcome to Arapiles - drop to one star

Willyabrup - The Organ Pipes
Heaven Calling - one star

Willyabrup - The Organ Pipes
Integrity - two stars

Willyabrup - Beginners Wall
Close Call - one star
Layback Jack - two stars

Willyabrup - The Terrace
Silver - two stars

Willyabrup - Peach Face
Well Stoned - drop to one star

Gracetown
Barefoot - two stars
Joint Effort - two stars

Cosy Corner - Wave Wall
Innocent Looks - one star
Big Girls Blouse - one star
Wipe Out - one star

Cosy Corner - Main Wall
Loose Lips - two stars
Chick Point - one star
Cut Crystal - one star


Ryan - 26 Mar 2015

I would maintain the star for Sinuosity, and the bolted route that, while partly retrobolts Percy Pigsville, is very good. Not sure if it currently gets stars but it is worthy of probably two. Shame about the controversial nature of it.

Heavy Metal... arhhh thats a tough one! Sure it's cruxy but damn it is still an excellent climb both before and after a ball tearer of a move (ok maybe I'm a little biased on this one!)


Remi - 27 Mar 2015

Some I can comment on or converge with your rating Krish:

Rockfish Dreaming - 1 star
One For The Road - 3 stars (maybe not consistent but it must be good given the traffic!!)
Sinuosity - 1 star (still a worthy climb and much better than High Reel at the same grade for example)
Golden Buttress - 2 stars
Charity - no stars
Heavy Metal - 2 or 3 stars (many get psyched about that one)
Welcome to Arapiles - 1 star


Neil - 27 Mar 2015

One for the road = 3 stars. not sure why it wouldn't be ??
Heavy Metal = 3 stars.
washed up punks = 1 star.


Ross Weiter - 27 Mar 2015

Proof is in the pudding, not in opinioneering. Routes with most chalk on them are the best climbs. Routes that get done all the time are the best climbs. That is why people do them.


Logan - 1 Apr 2015

Don't agree with you there Ross. The climbs that get done the most are the easiest, most accessible, and best protectable. I don't think these three things necessarily make the best routes. Space Face at Gracetown along with Dessert, Acidj,and KGB at Willies and Bee Free at Wallcliffe are all really good. Some are frequented and some not mainly due to accessibility.


Ross - 2 Apr 2015

Perhaps we are both right(ish). Climbs which are easy, accessible and well protected ARE excellent climbs (they give joy to more people!). But just because a climb misses any or all of these attributes does not mean that it is not just as excellent. Even routes with obvious "flaws" such as Rape and Pillage can be classics....I will never forget that unique start!! So fair comment from Logan to pull me up and I am joining the star wars - my 3 star classics are:
Wilys: Totally Awesome, Fat Chance, One for the Road, Golden Buttress, Dolphin Smiles, Fishing with Dynamite, Hope, Stainless Steel, Heavy Metal, Mobjob, Rape and Pillage, Sirius, Blondes Have More Fun, Stormcock, Corpus Delecti, Use no SLCDs.
Moses: Wheely Things
Bob's: many... I esp like Magnus and Altered States as both are "memorably weird" unfortunately often wet, Hollow Promises, Juggernaut, Shaved Cat...., Elongate, Black Lung, The Fin
Walcliffe: Fun Love and Joy, B Free


Peter T - 5 May 2015

Hope I'm not too late with this.... Just wondering if you are picking up on an old source of new route info, namely Western Climber from way back when. They always had a New Routes section, and I think older issues pre-dated this info being available electronically. Just as an example, have you picked up on a route at Willys that by pure coincidence just happens to be mine?! It's in the Feb-Apr 2001 Western Climber: Mid-Wall Crisis on Inner Space Wall, 20m, Grade 20, full details are there. I think it's possible this source of info could have been missed, as neither this climb nor the other one in that issue of WC (Palace of the Brine at West Cape Howe) made it into the April 2002 West Australian Rock. I don't know what range of WC's might not have been sourced by various means for info, but I have hard copies from Oct/Nov 1999.


Krish - 6 May 2015

Hey Peter I have not got access to or looked at any copies of WC to check new route info. If you are able to go through your copies and send me any new route details for Welly Dam, Castle Rock (Dunsborough), Smiths Beach, Moses, Willyabrup, Gracetown, Wallcliffe, Bobs Hollow or Cosy Corner that would be great. My email is [email removed].


Peter T - 6 May 2015

OK Krish, I'm happy to scan my copies and email to you - might take a few days. But I'm keen to know how far back should we go? Likely further than my first = Oct-Nov 1999, as Margaret River Rock guide dates from March 1996. Can someone please fill the gap? Also new route info may also have been loaded into this CAWA site after a certain date, and so there may be no need to go WC back issues after a certain date? Any comments from those in the know would be good.


Krish - 7 May 2015

Cheers Peter that is appreciated. I've scanned all the CAWA Climbing Talk and First Ascent forums for new route info so should have everything that was listed on there. I reckon it is worth scanning all available copies of Western Climber. I understand it is a ask but it would be great to make sure we capture as much info as possible. If others have older editions available it would be great to see them too.


Peter T - 11 May 2015

I've checked all Western Climbers from Feb 1999 to mid 2003 (when the CAWA site started taking new route info), and have sent the two items that I found at Willys to Krish. I would expect the release of the last guide approx March 1996 might have caused a flurry of activity, which means that Western Climbers for all of 1996, 1997 and 1998 would be good to scan - does someone have those?


Krish - 12 May 2015

Thanks Peter.

Keep climbing with us

Keep climbing with us

Keep climbing with us