Climbing Talk
Review of "Perth Rock" guide (Aug 2013)
Started by Ross
·
·
6 replies
Archived thread
Replies are closed. Some details, such as access rules and gate codes, may be out of date.
Ross - 10 Oct 2013
James - 11 Oct 2013
Great review Ross! I was unsure wether to buy it or not and you have confirmed my apprehension. I think you managed to stay as objective as possible considering you personal stake in the issue. :)
Z - 11 Oct 2013
Great review Ross. I picked up a copy more for the bouldering than the climbing however like you said... There are a number of mistakes in both route locations as well as the name of climbers in the photos... I swear Brian Tan looks like a different person in every photo. I was a little disappointed that the guide was $55 and in black and white considering the Grampians bouldering guide is in full colour and only $40. Nevertheless, I do like the graphics for the bouldering to post.
Z - 11 Oct 2013
Topos**
John B - 11 Oct 2013
I hear the glue's not that great, and one at least is coming appart.
Peter - 15 Oct 2013
Thats a bitchy rant, not a review!!....if we are being honest.
I think it says more about the authors ego...enjoy climbing, not bitching.
Ang - 15 Oct 2013
A highly revealing review Ross, nice work :)
Perhaps a quick email to the author of the new guide is in order.