Bolting
Re-bolting of "Morning Glory" at Stathams
Started by Glenn
·
·
66 replies
Archived thread
Replies are closed. Some details, such as access rules and gate codes, may be out of date.
Glenn - 27 Sep 2005
I am not sure if CAWA keeps a database of rebolted routes....We replaced the original rusted mild steel carrots over the weekend as follows:
Climb: "Morning Glory" at Stathams
Bolts Replaced: 2,3,4,5 (numbered ground up)
Replacement Date: 27/9/2005
Bolt Type: Ramset M10, 120mm Stainless Steel Studs
Glue: Ramset Maxima Epoxy Glue
Notes: Hangers to be added in the next week or so.
Installer: Glenn Sharrock
Cost: $48
Face - 27 Sep 2005
Fantastic Glenn!
Did you have the first accentionists' permission??
Very touchy subject this one.
Wombat - 27 Sep 2005
120mm !
Don't you trust your own gluing ??
FA's don't generally need contacting if replacing bolts like for like IMO. Hardly a sensitive issue in WA.
Numbat - 27 Sep 2005
I'm surprised that anyone would bother re-bolting that climb - there are others in much more need for rebolting.
Also, did you get the first ascensionists permission to rebolt? If it were me, I'd be pretty pissed of if you didn't ask first.
Finally, is there any need to put fixed hangers on a grade 18 climb where carrots have served fine? Sure, the bolts probably need to be replaced sometime as they are only galvanised steel. But it’s not such a desperate climb that fixed hangers are needed. The bolts are reasonably well placed and unless you are a 3 footed midget, bolt plates can be easily placed (maybe not Bolt #1, which is a bit fat...) and I think fixed hangers on a lot of climbs are a bit of a waste of money and despoil the rock. But at least it won't be as bad as the incredibly ugly ring bolts that someone put all over Lama Rock.
Kris - 27 Sep 2005
Numbat,
Disagree. Just because it is only an 18 doesn't mean it is not deserving of fixed hangers. There are heaps and heaps of climbers out there that can only manage climbs around this grade and hangers can give them a bit more confidence.
Easy climbs are just as important as hard climbs. If you only bolted hard climbs buggar all climbers would actually be climbing!
Wicked
Kris - 27 Sep 2005
One more thing.........LONG LIVE THE RING BOLT!!
Look forward to seeing more of them!!
Saber-toothed poteroo - 27 Sep 2005
Speaking from the point of view of someone who can only just manage the grade, there are some nice places to stand when you're at the bolts... the only prob. was the first bolt - a bit too chubby for my bolt plates! Horses for courses I think. And the only prob. with the ring bolts at Llama Rock are the ones on the skyline - not so pretty.
And Kris, you have lots of people in Spain who agree with you..I'm sure they think we're crazy over here (maybe we are!)
And one more thing...I thought numbats were supposed to be timid creatures...
richard - 27 Sep 2005
As the above was rebolting done by a CAWA committee member I would point out the following from the CAWA Bolting Ethics;
"Bolts must be visually unobtrusive, especially in areas visited by the non-climbing public. The installer must strive to use the least conspicuous method of bolting and installation and minimise the number of bolts."
Regardless of non-CAWA opinion the above is what we're about, and it is disappointing that our committee did not "strive to use the least conspicuous method of bolting" which would have been hex head glue-ins.
Kris - 27 Sep 2005
Richard,
In who's opinion are hex bolts considered the least obtrusive?
Isn't Stathams Quarry a man made crag that in itself is visually obtrusive?
Who goes to the quarry....Drunks, addicts, climbers and people with an obsession for throwing old T.V's from the top??
Surely these peolple couldn't give a rats if the bolts are obtrusive or not
Ben - 27 Sep 2005
Heya,
Statham's is a quarry so is the need to keep the bolts unobtrusive for the viewing public, which is limited at a redundant quarry, so important? Obviously we don't want to go bolting everything within arms length and there is still an aesthetic value at the quarries but not to the extent as the 'natural rock' which is viewed by the non-climbing public.
Is a climb graded with clipping bolts and placing hangers in mind? If so, does it matter whether they be ringbolts, fixed hangers or hex bolts?
As for the FA's consent. Hmmm, which is more important; people's safety or one (or a few) persons pride? Sure, ask the FA's consent if you can but the safety of the climb must be paramount and any FA being asked to have their climb re-bolted should understand this. A re-bolt, after all, is (or should be) required to replace unsafe bolts, not to make the climb easier.
Just a few questions I think are worth the discussion.
Cheers
Wombat - 27 Sep 2005
I thought it was a strange choice for rebolting too. There are many worse climbs out there where re-bolting would be more beneficial.
Carrots are perfectly suitable for that sort of rock and that angle. P-bolts are no guarantee for safety. I have seen just as many carrots fall out as P-bolts - and both types fall out more than you think they would !
Don't confuse re-bolting with retrobolting.
Chill Out - 27 Sep 2005
Good on you Glenn,
Nice to see somebody taking a bit of initiative rather than thes moaning bloody minnies who exist to complain. If the FA cared that much they'd have rebolted it themselves anyway.
I'm sure replacing bolts on an eyesore of a quarry won't attract a mob of Greenpeace campiagners to your door. My goodness this crowd that are complaing are probably driving about in V8 spewing carbon into the air!!
Stop being so anal!
Dream On.....
Numbat - 27 Sep 2005
A few comments -
Retro- vs. Rebolting. To me, rebolting is putting the same or similar back in - hex head stainless to replace galvanised. Fixed hangers in place of carrots is retrobolting.
Quarries - these are now often not just a place for drunks, druggies and climbers. Many are now a part of CALM-managed regional parks or even national parks. They are now visited by hikers, picnickers, MTBers, families etc etc. Although CALM happily damages rock - both natural and artificial - I'd be pretty sure that they would be pissed off if others do it.
Certainly quarries are artificial rock faces and I don't actually care that much if someone does chip or put ugly ringbolts in them. But the point is that retrobolting (as against rebolting) should be discussed - particularly with the first ascensionist.
In the case of natural rock, ringbolts are often far too conspicuous and unsightly, particularly as in the case at Lama Rock.
Regarding Richard's comments about the CAWA bolting ethics, I agree with the extract that he put up. However I'm pretty sure that the MG re/retro(?)bolting was not CAWA Committee approved. In the recent issue of 'Western Climber', there was something about rebolting and it said that only stainless hex glue-ins would be used unless necessary. Fixed hangers on an 18 are usually not necessary and having climbed MG I don't see the need.
If it is too hard for you Kris, then go back to the plywood and plastic. What's next? Ring bolts on Pink Knickers?
Don't slap the route dude if you’re shaky at the grade.
richard - 27 Sep 2005
My point was that Glenn is listed on this site as a Cawa committee member. If he's resigned then he's free to follow his inclinations. If not then this is a committee action. And the question to the Chairman is, why is the Cawa committee not following the Cawa bolting guidelines (Also published on this site).
Toc - 28 Sep 2005
Just a couple of things I should say.
One: The first ascensionist is somewhere else, probably the US, possibly Switzerland. Very hard to find. I did speak to someone who knew him last night and was told that it is very unlikely he would object.
Two: Glenn didn't retro-bolt the line in that only the bolts that were there, were replaced.
Three: I'm not commenting on the choice of fixed hangers. There are going to be arguements both ways, but in any case, Glenn resigned from the committee due to work commitments early in the year.
Four: 75mm (max) hammered in carrots, (in quarried rock, one fat), have been replaced by glue ins 50mm longer.
Five: If Glenn is strong enough, and I think he is, it's great to see lively debate.
Cheers all,
Toc Foale (CAWA chairperson)
Glenn - 28 Sep 2005
Greets All:
I resigned from the CAWA committee some time ago, but even so I dont think there is a contradiction here. The bolting standard I used is widely accepted and has been tested in the field and in the laboratory. In fact, it is one of the standards presented by safer cliffs australia, and is widely used in Australia.
However I would advance the following comment in response to the questions and criticism advanced (which I am more than happy to discuss): My reasoning is as follows:
1. Rebolting in original style.
The original bolts were 50mm long mild steel, ground down to 5mm thick behind the bolt head -. No glue, they were corroded and even in their new state, they should be considered inadequate for rock climbing. The bolts pulled out smoothly under body weight on a short bar. Its obvious that this style is inadequate; as proven by the fact that such bolts are being replaced all over Australia with either glue-in-threaded- bar type bolts, P-bolts, or glue in carrots. For these reasons I don’t regard the "original style" as a valid replacement option.
On the issue of glue in machine bolts, to my knowledge there is no data on the performance of glue in carrots. Based on my 10 years of experience with glue in bolts in the mining industry, my opinion is that glue in carrots will have a much lower pull out strength than threaded bar since with GIC the threaded length is only around 40mm (grinding a pattern into the bolt surface has problems which I wont go into). If anyone can show me load tests on glue in carrots with (40mm of embedded thread) then I would be interested to see them, but until I do I am not placing these bolts. In my opinion these bolts might have a substantially lower safe working load than fully threaded glue in bars - that’s enough for me until I see some actual tests.
One standard bolting system adopted by Safer Cliffs Australia is 100mm Threaded Bar with dynamically rated glue. This system has been extensive tested and has a safe working load. This system has been in laboratory tested for rock climbing. I have a dozen or so articles on load testing of bolts if anyone is really interested in the technical specs !! If anyone thinks this is overkill then you should go away and investigate the manufactures load transfer curves and compare this against the dynamic loads generated in a fall.....
2. Why re-bolt that particular climb
I simply want to climb it! No other reason is required. If you have a climb you would like re-bolted do it yourself!!! (or better still ask CAWA to do it so that it is done properly !!! ).
3. Hangers:
As anyone whom has done this climb would know - it already has a hanger on bolt number 4 and also 2 ring bolts at the top ! Also, considering the fact that the quarry has been altered for climbing with shotcrete, blasting, scaling, large concreted-in poles at the top, and is covered in hangers on other climb, I don’t thinks a few more hangers are an issue.... In addition P-bolts or hangers are the accepted approach now in Australia. However I entirely respect and agree with the idea of minimal visual impact at natural cliffs!!
4. Another controversial issue:
At the risk of sounding inflammatory I would add that I removed the bash in carrots from Lifestyle-Refugees. These bolts pulled under body weight, and considering the huge run outs and poor quality of the rock I would suggest that this was an accident waiting to happen. I will replace these bolts shortly and I intend to ask to first ascentist if more bolts can be added. Any comments?
Kris - 28 Sep 2005
Hi Numbat (Would be nice to know who you really are?)
You miss the point completely! Just because you might be the next Chris Sharma or Ben Moon and find 18 grades easy and not worthy of bolts doesn't mean that they shouldn't be bolted!
There are far more climbers out there that find an 18 to be their limit for now and they have as much right to have a safely bolted climb as you do with your higher grade climbs!
Don't let your arrogance at being better than most climbers discriminate against them.
Sweet.
Danny - 28 Sep 2005
Numbat,
Quote: "Don't slap the route dude if you’re shaky at the grade."
And I thought a part of climbing was pushing yourself to new limits?
You have some very interesting ideas and what a great place to express them.
My2cents - 28 Sep 2005
Good work Glenn,
If more people focused their energy on "doing" instead of whinging we'd all be better off, I'm sure all these negative comments are making you ask yourself why you bothered..
As far as I'm aware Oz is the only place to use carrot bolts ?? In Europe etc all the common routes have FH or are Trad climbs, Keep up the good work, I'm sure youve considered the impact. Cheers
richard - 28 Sep 2005
Well anything's better than bashins. Still I don’t go along with the the-quarries-are-a-mess-lets-trash-them-anyway crowd. Where suitable (clips from a position where a climber is comfortably on balance) hex head bolts are the best, least obtrusive solution. Hangers should be reserved for difficult or strenuous clips.
An advantage of hangers is the continuous thread along the stud allowing better adherence of the glue. It is possible to get hex bolts with full length thread which would give similar adhesion. Although this would not be desirable as the protruding section of the bolt where bending occurs should be smooth. A retort from the hanger side would be that with the hanger tightened against the rock there is no significant bending. The response would be that the bolt is then permanently under stress, which does it no harm (assuming no SSC concerns) but which will load the glue and surrounding rock. The oldest hangers I've seen (in hard sandstone) were all loose.
A strong argument raised is that the hanger installation is done essentially according to an qualified procedure. While this is true, tests appear to be done a relatively short time after installation. Not after ten or fifteen years of thermal cycling. Further, it would seem reasonable to extrapolate the installation procedure from a threaded stud to a hex bolt with a long thread. Simple bending calcs on the protruding section should give sufficient confidence in the bolts strength. And the elimination of the permanent bolt stress imposed with hangers has got to be an improvement.
In the short term hangers may be better than some alternatives. Certainly four of the five P-bolts I’ve removed came out with a crowbar under very moderate pressure. You can’t exert much while dangling on a rope. I take the point that if one cares so much then get out there and replace the hangers. But there are an awful lot of bashins to replace first.
Glenn - 28 Sep 2005
Hi Richard (and everyone else)
Thanks for your comments.
I agree with you comments on the use of hex bolts with long thread lengths (say 80mm of thread and 20mm of threadless shank). I investigated this option and to date I have not been able to source such bolts - if you know of a source please let me know as this is a cheaper option. However, based on my calcs, I don’t believe 40mm of embedment is sufficient.
On the matter of long-term effects of thermal stress, cyclic load etc on glue in bolts. I agree these are important issues and this is why I an arguing for longer bolts (as opposed to shorter bolts). It may be that 80mm of embedment is not enough over time, or they may require replacing. With a good drill it only takes 1 minute to drill a 90mm deep hole so even doubling the depth is no great burden (and does’nt impact on the visual appearance of the system). Cost is another issue....
Please see below notes that came out of correspondence with others on the issue of fully threaded glue in carrots:
RE: Hex Bolts
I recently contact a couple of chaps over east who were involved an R & D project on bolt testing for RC - they are not aware of any testing on glue in carrots, but there is plenty of published work on threaded bars with different embedment lengths.
I have investigated fully threaded 316 hex bolts. They are available but I dont think the thread at the collars will work with our bolt plates (ie it will catch and apply bending moment to bolt). Also these bolts have only 8mm of effective diameter at the collar, compared to 10mm for a full shank bolts). What we really need is "partially threaded" hex bolts (say 100mm long M10 bolts with 80mm of thread, and 20mm of shank).
Some people roughen the surface of the hex bolt with an angle grinder; in my opinion this is non-ideal and besides potentially creating stress raisers, there will be a differential stiffness in bond which would create uneven load transfer along the axis of the bolt - break glue?
ie fine thread = high stiffness,
widely spaced ground holes = low stiffness
Also, how to create a uniform pattern? Damage to bolt strength due to careless grinding. We should aim to have a repeatable, process that is quality controlled rather than depending on the skill of someone with an angle grinder.
FYI: See load transfer graph for M10 threaded bar with Chemset 801 series.
Summary:
- threaded bar with 80mm of encapsulation: sigmaT = 10KN
- carrot (glue in with 40mm of encap) sigmaT = 2KN
"graph attached"
THE treasurer - 29 Sep 2005
A small point, folks.
That a CAWA member is on the committee does not necessarily imply that anything they do has committee knowledge let alone approval. Can't recall any discussion on it at any committee meeting.
And I would remember, I lead it by the skin of my teeth not so long ago, but before rebolting.
Quite sobering really - oh, and Richard, I disagree with you on the visual impact of quarries, they are man made and therefore fair game for the hilti crew, existing climbs on natural gear notwithstanding, o'course.
Peter T - 29 Sep 2005
No one (I think) answered Glenn's question re Lifestyle Refugees, the run-out Gr 14 a few metres left of MG. If the bolts could be pulled out by hand, then good on you for replacing them.
Should there be more bolts to make it safer? I think not. I have enjoyed this climb as a thought-provoking, careful exercise in controlled climbing. This is how the first ascensionist intended it, and this is how it should remain. I would urge all serious climbers to develop and take pride in an ability to lead "run-out" climbs, because if you don't meet them in WA, you will surely encounter them elsewhere in Oz/the globe. But also it can be very satisfying - a whole new dimension to climbing, in which leading is actually a totally different kettle of fish from top-roping or leading a closely-spaced clip-up. So Glenn and others, please don't over-sanitise our climbs, we need a variety of styles.
richard - 29 Sep 2005
On your figures at beginning of life a stud has five times the pull-out strength of a 40mm thread, which is only 200kg? One may wonder if after a few years the pull-out strengths might not be comparable. The attraction with glue-in machine bolts is the benign nature of the service. For almost their entire lives they sit in an unstressed state, waiting for the once in a blue moon when someone falls. Hangers are tightened up, putting an outward force on the bolt. So day and night, rain and shine, the bolt puts stress on the glue and the rock. Eventually you’d think the glue will creep, or the glue or the rock will crack a little to relieve the stress, and the hanger will be a little lose and someone will tighten it up again. This may not be true in granite. Best would be a long hex bolt with a long thread.
Modifying bolts I don’t think is a good idea. Hand roughening, the uncontrolled introduction of massive surface flaws, is one of the main objections to bashins. It’s not a fatigue situation, but the stress raisers introduced can not be good.
Standard thread is 40. Nothing much else is easily available. Although you can have anything if you order in quantity. It might be worth looking into ordering a custom lot of 100 or so. SS is expensive anyway it shouldn’t be much more. I hope. It’d be a matter of finding enough people to share out the bolts. I take it 304 would be sufficient for inland locations?
Is anyone interested in a part share of a custom lot of SS hex bolts?
Marianne - 29 Sep 2005
Peter, I absolutely agree that climbs shouldn't be overly sanitised - the climbs I have firmly etched in my mind as epics are the trad climbs I've led! The only point I would make about the 14 though is the lack of well-protected 14s around the place. I think it would actually add variety to the 14 grade if one was nicely protected!! (I'm thinking of the Mountain Quarry 14 near Playboy, which I couldn't find much protection on)What seems to happen is the hard climbs get well-protected and the 'easy' climbs get left as near-solos. Please correct me if I'm wrong because there's nothing I like better than spotting a well-protected 14 :)
So Glenn, I guess what I'm saying is I'm happy with some extra bolts (only if the FA doesn't mind, of course)
Marianne - 29 Sep 2005
ps Grade 14 slab climbs don't count...I'm in a slab-hating phase!!
Numbat - 29 Sep 2005
Looks like we've opened a(nother) can or worms here, folks!
Firstly, for those that don't bother properly reading other people's comments, I am not against the REBOLTING of existing climbs that have sub-standard bolts. Rather I’m against the RETROBOLTING of existing climbs.
If the bolts that were on MG were only banged-in 50 mm galvanised mild steel, well they should have be replaced a long time ago. Actually, they shouldn’t have gone in at all. Roake, you’re a bad boy! Glen - well done for taking the initiative to replace them.
Incidentally Glen, the bolts I use are usually glue-in 316 hex head, between 75 and 120 mm long with about 40 mm of thread. I have also used others in the past that have about 75 mm of thread and 25 mm of unthreaded, I’ll tack down where I got them from. I do sometimes use fixed hangers and when I use ring bolts - which isn’t very often - I use ones that have a 20 mm ID ring and have 105 mm of thread and 15 mm of unthreaded shaft.
There are a lot of other climbs that need to be rebolted - the first bolt on Superslab Direct is a gal-steel bolt, also probably just a bang-in carrot. Even worse are the dodgy pitons on Bootiful and Supernova. No need to worry about the piton on Major - that fell out a long time ago!
However the way that I see it, a climb should (usually!) be rebolted in the ‘same spirit’ at it was done by the first ascentionist. To replace the existing (dodgy) bolts with something significantly different is not rebolting - it is retrobolting. Replacing dodgy 50 mm mild steel hex carrots with 100 mm glue-in 316 hex heads - fine! The climb will be heaps safer - but still in the same spirit as it was previously. On the other hand, replacing 50 mm mild steel hex carrots with fixed hangers significantly changes the climb and to me is retrobolting. Whether or not there was one fixed hanger there already is irrelevant. With the ringbolts that someone put up the top, well, they have made the climb significantly safer as there is now no need to scramble over the choss at the top and to set up a belay that causes rubble to fall on the seconder.
In the paragraph above, I wrote “a climb should (usually!) be rebolted in the ‘same spirit’ at it was done by the first ascentionist”. By this I mean there are exceptions. The location of the bolts on MG was good. Despite Roake using dodgy 50 mm hex gal-bolts, they are in well thought-out places. Whether you are short or tall, they are relatively easy to slip a bolt plate over them and to clip. There are other climbs however where, unless you are 6’4” or more, are very difficult to clip. There are a few people around that seem to forget - perhaps purposely - that not everyone is 6’4” and they seem to enjoy watching other, shorter people being freaked out on what would otherwise be good climbs. In other cases there are climbs that have been bolted very unsafely and in a manner that shows poor form - Gibraltar Rock is a good example - where many climbs were bolted by someone abseiling from the top and putting bolts seemingly at random every 30 or 40 metres apart. I’m not really into 60 to 80 metre falls on cheese-grater rock, so I have quite happily put extra bolts on Gibraltar Rock. If someone is a bastard or just a fool and bolts a climb without giving any thought to other climbers, then I have no objections to rebolting or retrobolting. But MG is not one of these and consequently I don’t see the need for fixed hangers.
For those people who claim that not everyone can climb a non-p-bolted grade 18, then simply don’t do it. Go and practice on easier climbs until you are good enough and then do it. Bring yourself up to the level of the rock, don’t bring the rock down to you. If you want to climb a ladder, go to Bunnings and buy one.
Wombat - 29 Sep 2005
I don't think the routes on Gibraltar Rock need any more bolts. There is a balance of runout old school climbs vs "safe-ish" newer ones. Dockyard Wall, Illusions of Grandeur, Possum and the other nameless old school classics deserve to be left as is with their 30m+++ runouts. The newer climbs - Sucked in Ben, Rooster Carnage, Let the Fun Begin, Dinosaur, Joint Venture etc have enough bolts to keep things relatively sane. As Peter said, climbing an easier run out climb can be just as much of an achievement as climbing a harder clip up. We need to maintain the variety that already exists in WA and acknowledge that both of these styles are warranted.
It's nice to see the other comments from closet marsupials on the subject. Long live those with hairy noses !
The number of people claiming to be bolters seems a little high given the amount of new routes that appear in WA over the years….
One last Q; assuming a glued in carrot does pull out @ 2kN, how the hell can you generate an outward force of 2kN on a route like MG let alone 10kN ?!?!
Glenn - 29 Sep 2005
Hi Richard:
I am in a bit of a rush and out for a couple of days so this is a quick reply:
Please count me in for 50 bolts.
I also sent out for a quote as well so we can see whom lands the best deal.
My email address is:
[email removed]
I have asked for a quote on 316 stainless steel in:
1. 100 bolts, M10 100mm long with 80mm of thread
2. 100 bolts, M10 120mm long with 100mm of thread
Numbat: I would greatly appreciate info on where you sourced those bolts with 75mm of thread.
Cheers
Glenn
Wombat - 29 Sep 2005
just get a die and make your own.
of course then you'll have to live with the extra SCF of a cut thread vs a rolled thread which will no doubt lower the holding power down to an unacceptable 7kN.... pfft. of course SCF is only going to manifest itself under tensile stress due to bending and this will be a seconodary stress most likely leading to local plastic deformation and extremely minimal impact on bolt capcity.
i'd be alot more worried about the glue. its hard to get in with paws. i wish i had opposable thumbs !
Jason - 29 Sep 2005
God, why don't you guys get into the 21st century. Bolted climbs with hangers or staples exist all over the world, in every rock type. Forget about carrot bolts and make the climbs safe for all grades and future climbers!
Cricketbat - 30 Sep 2005
Huh, a die. Why didn't I think of that. The only reason to order a special lot is the non standard length, and the chance to get my personal monogram on the head. Sure to impress the high rollers.
saber-toothed poteroo - 30 Sep 2005
Hmm, bolts in gritstone? Don't think so! Long live variety (and a few head climbs to dream about and test your nerves on)
ps wombat, I wish I had opposable thumbs too - though I quite like my eyes... they're a little bit out of the ordinary :-)
Mikl Law - 30 Sep 2005
Longer stainless bolts (80+ mm) are good, similar to rings, but have no possibility for twisting loads to loosen them. They must have an unthreaded shoulder, and any glue in anchor should be cleaned before use. Threaded rod is good in theory, but nuts come loose. Eyebolts/U's CAN be be made unobtrusive, but not as much as SGABs (stainless glued anchors bolts) without hangers, it depends on the visibilty and situation. Rorke Muhlen is living in Melbourne if it's his route.
michael ([email removed])
Ross - 1 Oct 2005
Well done Glenn, the Morning Glory buttress is blast-shattered non-granite intrusion and carrots do not belong there in this day and age. Good luck in future endeavours. I do favour hex-head glue-ins, as you know, but no worries about hangers in unnatural environments like quarries. The ringbolts on top of MG were put in by me after the hangers were stolen off the old expansion bolt loweroffs.
Long runouts like on Lifestyle Refugees are OK with me personally but the bolts must be bloody certified super safe else it is deckout and curtains. I'm surprised the guys who put the carrots in there would risk the liability law suit (by clearly not following current practices), but hey, it is their money (note: this risk is electable - you can see the runouts and carrots from the ground, but natural selection can be a cruel thing).
Ross - 2 Oct 2005
Another thing. This "glued in carrot" that keeps getting mentioned by contributors above? Has anyone experienced one? I cannot imagine why anyone would grind a threaded hex bolt into a carrot shape and the glue it in. Perhaps this is just a misunderstanding some people have? So I thought I would write this:
It is important to distinguish between a carrot and what I call the Glued-In Hex Bolt (which is mouthful so let's call it GHB). From the outside they look similar: there is a hexagonal (6-sided) bolt head looking at ya. Some even have a button (circular) head. This is beccause both are made from the same starting point material: a hex head machine bolt.
The GHB is bacically the unmodified hex head machine bolt; when installed it can be distinguished simply by having some glue present around it and the fact that the hole is larger than the bolt. This is because a 12mm hole is normally drilled and 10mm bolt used in it, the 1mm annular space is filled by glue.
The carrot visually is jammed into the hole. At the point of entry to rock, bolt diameter=hole diamater. However to confuse things some carrot installers splay cheap glue around the entry point to seal it in, presumably for corrosion protection of the subsurface galvanised bolt. This does nothing for holding strength.
Under the surface, what you do not see, is vastly different.
The GMB is typically 70-120mm long and is held in by glue. It is not ground down. The glue sticks to the bolt by virtue of machined threads, about 1/2 of the bolt length is threaded in the stock item (avoid fully threaded ones). It holds in the hole by glue.
The carrot is typically 50mm long and is ground with an angle grinder into a carrot (tapering) shape and jammed into the hole. It holds by deformation at the area of contact.
Why some people still use carrots and not GHBs is because they are cheap and less messy to install: $1 for a 3/8"x2" carrot, but $6 for a 10x100 GBH (cost of bolt+glue, say Hilti). For glued in ringbolt this is more like $10 each by the way. Also, gluing is a horrible job, even when not on a rope and does not lend itself to 1-2 bolt jobs as the mixing nozzle gets thrown out at the end of day, which wastes glue.
Bad installations: someone made a point about badly installed glue ins. It is possible to screw up a GMB installation (wrong mixing nozzle, old glue, weak/wrong glue, dirty hole, badly spread glue) just like it is possible to screw up a carrot (fat, overdriven, insufficient contact with rock): at Wellington dam some contractor-glued ANCHORS were spun by hand (now removed). But a properly installed GMB will always be stronger than a properly installed carrot (there is much of data on this and is just beyond argument) and will not creep.
I would urge people to use GMBs wherever visibility is an issue, and as replacement for carrots. CAWA could make funds available for rebolting jobs, as it is expensive and the motivation is low as you normally do not get mentioned in a guidebook, unlike the speedy FA with carrots.
Amen.
richard - 3 Oct 2005
Well, that's what you get for dissent. We climbed in Statham's yesterday. Thought MG would be a plesant and airy outing. Imagine our lack of surprise to find -
studs !
This is far more challenging than hex bolts. So the hangers didn't last long or are they still coming? We had a good day. Gun Barrel Highway, an old fashioned 16 with a purely natural crux. No arguments about how best to deface the rock.
But one can't deny the merit of the two excellent Weiter bolted climbs right of MG.
Time to get out the stud-puller.
Danny - 3 Oct 2005
I am pretty sure that Glenn originally stated that hangers were to come in the next week or two....it's all the way up there at the top of the page....a long, long way up!
Kris - 3 Oct 2005
Danny,
Here is a perfect example for the need for hangers or p-bolts just to get back to the top of this over technical wanked up page of nonsense!
When no one wants to hear your side of the arguement just bore them to death with technical crap.
Carrot Bolt Kris (Patent pending)
Glenn - 3 Oct 2005
Hi All:
I should get time to add the hangers this week. I thought it was best to leave them off until the glue sets...
On Richards comment on stud pulling I decline to comment :-)
Cheers
Glenn
Glenn- - 3 Oct 2005
Thanks to all for your comments and encouragement. The main reason I advertised the re-bolting is to gain input before I pursue the rebolting of other climbs using the appropriate bolting systems.
There is no point rebolting if people get upset and pull them out (we all have much better things to do with our time and energy would be better spent replacing bolts, rather than chopping them !! ).
I dont intend to alter the existing bolting on any climb unless there is some overwhelming factor such as poor quality rock at the site of the existing bolts (if the climb is run out I am not going to alter it without FA input).
I intend to write a technical article for Western Climber outlining what I have found in the literature and how this applies to rebolting / bolting in WA - we are behind the times and have much to learn.
Toc - 4 Oct 2005
Just for Kris's benefit. The technical stuff is what will keep you alive. If you can't deal with it, don't denigrate those who can, because if they don't get the "technical stuff" right, people will die, particularly those people who only climb on bolts and just assume everything will be all right because bolts are automatically safe. Bolts are not automatically safe. It depends completely on the technicalities and everytime YOU climb on bolts YOU are assuming someone got the "boring technical stuff" right. For YOUR sake let's all hope THEY do.
Enjoy your climbing,
Toc.
Kris - 4 Oct 2005
Thanks Toc,
Do i have to test every bolt i use in the future or just continue as i have HOPING they hold if my fat arse should i fall on them?
I found it interesting that a discussion on rebolting turned into an ego driven technical lecture.
But thankyou for steering me in the right direction.
Happy climbing also.
Toc - 4 Oct 2005
Hi Kris,
I didn't notice the debate being ego driven. Most of the people contibuting to that particular debate deal with highly technical matters in their work pretty much on a continuous basis so a discussion of the technical aspects of bolting isn't necessarily ego driven. Technical discussions are just normal life, and in the case of bolts for climbing, they are life or death matters, not to mention the fact that we as a climbing community don't own the rock and we do have to think about the consequences of our actions on the wider non-climbing community. This website is not only the most appropriate place for this discussion to appear, but the ability to have those discussions is one of the reasons the website exists.
And yes, actually you should think about the safety of each bolt you climb on. It's noticeable from previous submissions that you are pro-bolt. One of the things you will learn from using trad gear is this fact; you and you alone are responsible for your own safety. This is still true when climbing on someone else's bolts. Your life and your continued ability to access climbing areas depends on other people and maybe yourself getting the technical aspects and the aesthetics right. So encourage discussion.
Cheers,
Toc.
Kris - 4 Oct 2005
Toc,
I fully agree that it is my responsibility for my safety when climbing and a gladly accept all this responsibility.
I will NEVER blame anyone else for any accidents i may have even if the bolt or cam i use might fail, i just don't believe in it, it was my choice to use them.
I do however believe, purely from my own experience, that a debate works best by keeping the subject matter as simple as possible. I am pro-bolt but only where Trad can't be used (love my cams).
I just wish we could join the rest of the world and do away with bloody carrots and hexes. I know of two separate people who have used these bolt types only to have the bolt plate come off with the draw attached! I can't see how a fixed hanger or P-bolt would let this happen?
So thanks to everyone for my science/geology/physics lesson on bolts and rock, but I think simple works best. Just my opinion and i know many disagree, thats your opinion.
Wicked
Numbat - 4 Oct 2005
Hi Folks,
Yes, I've also seen bolt-plates come off hex bolts. They come off because the climber puts them on incorrectly - with the big part of the keyhole up the top and the karabiner through the small part of the keyhole.
Karabiners also come of P-bolts and fixed hangers. They usually come off because dirt gets in the spring and the gate doesn't close, although other things can happen as well. The old Chouinard crabs use to often fall off as they would crack, just like their cams. By the way, I believe that Chouinard changed it's name to 'Black Diamond'.
Kris - 4 Oct 2005
Sorry Numbat,
But the plates were put on CORRECTLY on both occasions! But the little buggars still managed to come off the bolt with draw attached!
Worried
Neil - 4 Oct 2005
There are only two main ways bolt plates can come off:
1) they were put on by a wombat - since you say it was on correctly we can rule that one out :)
2) a skinny karabiner was used. i.e lightweight one or a wire gate.
Just FYI Kris - i have seen draws unclip themselves from P bolts, U bolts and fixed hangers during normal climbing and falls.
I think all types of bolts have their merits and their suitability varies depending on the circumstances involved. You'd have to be a bit naive to say there is no place for carrots or glue in machine bolts. But likewise you'd have to acknowledge that carrots are only suitable in certain situations.
richard - 4 Oct 2005
Aah, so we've all decided to beat the *** out of poor Kris. I have seen bolt plates fall off bolts. That was because people sometimes do a very strange thing. They clip the carabiner into the slot where the bolt is supposed to fit and delicately hang the boltplate upsidedown on the the bolt. Usually done only by those in the learning/survival phase. The simple faith in equipment implicit in such action is very touching.
Di - 4 Oct 2005
Well Kris it may be 'technical wank' and 'boring' to you and I will admit to my eyes glazing over while reading these posts, but I'm EXTREMELY thankful that the people who are giving their time and money to put bolts in are having the discussion of how to do it more safely!
Sure as hell makes me feel a lot safer knowing that they are trying their best to ensure MY safety when I clip their bolts.
So Glenn, Toc, Ross, et al. please keep it up!!!! (The boring technical stuff and the bolting.)
Kris - 4 Oct 2005
Neil,
I may not be a wombat but i believe there is NEVER a situation where carrots are suitable....not today. We might as well go back to using pitons.
Aren't carrots just a glorified version of pitons??
Numbat - 4 Oct 2005
Yes, a carrot is a glorified piton, just like a Bunning's ladder is a glorified P-bolt.
Without pitons, most of the world's great climbs would not have been done in the 60's and 70's. We would have had to waited until Kris turned up with his Bunning's ladder!
Long live the Lost Arrow!
Ross - 4 Oct 2005
Ah, wanking. Someone once said said that you either admit to having done it or you are still doing it.
Now to hangers going off bolts. I have done some tests. It is possible for a properly clipped hanger to come off a 3/8" bolt if a lightweight carabiner is used and the bolt sticks out a bit.
If a 10mm bolt (which has a much larger head than the 3/8") or a normal-sized carabiner is used I have not managed achieve this. I guess it would take a lot of deformation.
Glenn's forthcoming article on bolting is long overdue, but given that most people will lose the WC, would it not be better to post it, and links to bolting sites, on a separe subpage on the CAWA web? I'm sure evryone can read the available info and make up their own mind.
Angus - 4 Oct 2005
Numbat - just because Bunnings wasn't around in the 60s (maybe it was?), doesn't mean we shouldn't shop there now. Equally, the fact that 'great climbs' were protected using carrots in the 60s etc. does not mean we should trust them when safer alternatives are available.
We could go on like this for weeks....
Numbat - 4 Oct 2005
Hi Angus,
yes, but there is a difference between 'safer alternatives' that are in the same spirit as the original climb, and 'safer alternatives' that are not. Replacing a dodgy carrot with a ring bolt that can be clipped while blind drunk and in the dark is very different from replacing it with a safe glue-in hex.
Where's your sense of adventure? It seems that many climbers these daze don't have one and unless it's nice and warm and there's a coke machine in the corner and P-bolts ladders, then they can't climb.
Kris - 4 Oct 2005
Numbat,
The 60's and 70's are long gone mate....let go. Pitons are long gone....time for carrots to rest in peace in a museum somewhere! They've served their purpose. P-bolts have one advantage in that they offer a way out should the route beat you. And you'll never better yourself unless you push your limits...at times we push too far.
One question: How is a p-bolt like a bunnings ladder? You don't use the bolts to climb on only as a means to clip for some protection if you fall. Maybe this concept is beyond the understanding of a timid ant-eating marsupial such as yourself.
Next
Angus - 5 Oct 2005
Hi Numbat,
Point taken, but I disagree none the less.
I thought the love of carrots in this state was on account of their visual qualities (also debatable), rather than their ability to make climbers 'hard'. When you stop talking about safety and start talking about toughening people up, this becomes a (far more) subjective debate and loses relevance as far as I am concerned.
Saber-toothed poteroo - 5 Oct 2005
To all the people out there who worship at the altar of p-bolts, please be aware that there are other ways to climb - it is your right to turn climbing into a sport rather than an adventure (that's why it's called sport climbing), but there are others who still want the adventure. Some countries, like Spain and France, have opted for sport climbing, which is fine if certain aesthetics are adhered to. In Western Australia we seem to be in transition, and some people don't appear to have any idea about aesthetics. There is a wonderful photo on the front of the Perth climbing guide book of a climber on Llama Rock. This photo would be ruined now because someone felt the need to put p-bolts on the skyline. Never once while I was climbing in Spain did I see a line of p-bolts placed with such blatant disregard to aesthetics. It looks bad, and if non-climbers/CALM notice it looks bad (and other lines like it) and develop a policy for climbing in WA, there is a big chance we won't get to enjoy climbing in the same way we do now.
So, all you p-bolters out there, be aware that (1) people who are out for adventure have just as much right to the rock as you have and (2) when you're p-bolting, be aware of the issues, and bolt accordingly
Kris - 5 Oct 2005
Saber Tooth,
Point taken. Still disagree. I have photos of the rock in question and unless you blow it up 500% you can't see the bolts you mention.
Don't confuse my support for hangers and p-bolts with a desire to make every climb a sport climb...far from it! Trad should be the first option, mixed (combination of trad and sport)the second option and then sport as the third option where no trad can be placed.
I will however admit to an absolute hatred of carrots and see no place for them in this world now that there are far better options. Those of you that berate the p-bolt seem misunderstand why i am in favour of them. You dont't use them to climb like a "ladder". You still have to climb the ROCK, clip the bolt and clip the rope! How is that different to clipping a carrot besides the obvious extra waste of time of placing a plate?
If nothing else this forum has been fun and interesting and demonstrates we have a long way to go before we can agree on one single topic
Mint
Rod - 6 Oct 2005
well done Glenn...now that sensible pro is there i bet the critics will dump their forum ethics and proceed to use it, many of them thinking "thank god glenn spent that $48".
rod, a rebolter elsewhere on the planet where its seemingly more appreciated.
Numbat - 6 Oct 2005
Rod, Kris and others...
you continually confuse 'rebolting' with 'retrobolting'. You also seem to continually confuse 'carrots' with 'glue-in hex heads'. How come?
Rod, regarding you comment of "i bet the critics will dump their forum ethics and proceed to use it" - well, what choice do we have when you force your ethics (or lack of) onto me? And before you throw that back at me, MG was bolted about 13 years or so ago using carrots - which, I agree, need to be replaced, as do most carrots. But you fail to see that in those 13 years MG has been climbed many times and no one has ever complained before that the hex-heads were difficult to clip or made the climb too hard or went against their ethics - so why now?
Certainly people have complained that the zinc-plated carrots did not meet specs on safety grounds and even did not meet official CAWA bolting guidelines, but that is all. The 'ethics' issues of carrots have never stopped anyone climbing on MG.
Kris - 6 Oct 2005
Numbat,
No confusion here. Rebolting is replacing like bolts, Retro is replacing old bolts with different bolts...correct?
I just hate carrots and hexes because i believe better alternatives exist. Simple.Just my opinion nothing else.
We should do dinner
Rod - 6 Oct 2005
even if it had been replaced by new carrots, the spirit of the climb would have been altered...whether you call it retro or rebolt.
my point on ethics relates to the subsequent climber, as you have alluded to. assume that glenn et al had left the original protection in place but put in the new shiny gear resulting in 2 methods of protection. would you seriously choose to clip to the rusty gear and not the new stuff? if the answer is yes, its easy to leave it there.
based on the various guidelines and flame wars in multiple forums, climbing community convention seems to be that with the fa's permission the equipper can re-engineer it almost any way they want. i didn't set the rule but do try to follow it, as do most.
my take on this situation is that these guys took those conventions into consideration. glenn et al had the guts to stand up and say they re-equipped a route. i wanted to stand up and be counted as saying thanks because its a generally costly task that tends to draw criticism as in this case but it actually merits praise...as you acknowledge.
Toc - 7 Oct 2005
The great thing about discussion is that it often gets results. The result in this case is that Glenn, CAWA and a few others, me included will be getting a batch of hex head bolts of sufficient length with extra thread length to make us all happy. All, except those who are pushing their limits and need ring bolts to do so. CAWA is getting the bolts so they will be available if someone needs a few and doesn't want to buy a 100, and they will be sold to climbers at only just a little more than cost.
justin - 7 Oct 2005
What a waste of time, effort, discussion and money. With these sort of attitudes about embracing the new bolting techniques, you have insured that the crags around Perth stay relatively empty and the climbs will not be done in there current state, still we can all go bouldering instead!
Toc - 7 Oct 2005
Hi Justin,
Funny, I still climb. Most of my friends climb, and they even manage to climb using hex heads, but you know the really scary thing, a lot of them use natural gear, even scarier, some of them do onsite leads of new climbs, from the ground up, with no prior inspection, and I can tell you for sure, I have never had bigger kick than that. Open your eyes, there's a lot more going on in climbing than ring bolts. If you find new climbs that need bolting, then you are of course free to go buy the bolts, the glues, the tools and bolt them yourself. But I'll tell you now, you bolt something that can be done on natural gear, I strongly suggest you don't own up to it. No-one will have the slightest bit of respect for it.
Toc
rod - 8 Oct 2005
numbat, i was on a bit of a troll for you in the earlier 2 posts because you just seemed so worked up about it, i tried but couldn't pass on it. please accept my apologies for being so infantile.
justin, the hex head bolt outcome is actually pretty good. well installed quality hex heads are pretty safe once you've learn't how to use them and they save you lugging the full trad rack. on my last trip home i didn't clip any but that was simply because i was in sport and bouldering mode (mostly ended up solo/bouldering low fall consequence new traverses over the ocean). under different circumstances i'd clip a decent hex head. i hope you've already started to renovate routes but if not there's so many fixer-uppers out there in need of attention that i'm sure you'll find a huge number where permissions to instal rings are readily forthcoming...though you may attract a little heat in the process