First Ascents
Mountain quarry new route
Started by Emil
·
·
70 replies
Archived thread
Replies are closed. Some details, such as access rules and gate codes, may be out of date.
Emil - 18 Sep 2009
Far RHS of the City Limits wall (the first, often dirty wall on your left as you enter the quarry)
Choad Warrior 15m 26
Follow the obvious line of Fixe bolts past flake lines. Subtract one style point if you thrash up the arete to the anchors after the last bolt...
Lower offs shared with Pat's old project to the left though I will replace these as they suck a little.
Scott - 18 Sep 2009
'Chaos' should it be? Cool will have to try it Saturday.
How's the other one going? Last time I tried it, it had this annoying red tag on the first bolt. Very difficult getting a draw through there...
Scott - 18 Sep 2009
Oh I see. Funny
Confused - 18 Sep 2009
Mmm.. I don't.
Scott - 18 Sep 2009
Urban Dictionary - 'Choad'
steve.k - 18 Sep 2009
is it non chipped ?
Ross - 19 Sep 2009
Finally..... I had a look at it years ago but it was beyond me. Funny it lasted that long given where it is.... Well done, very worthwhile if yer up to it....
Jeff M - 19 Sep 2009
Well done but chipped or non chipped? Did you step up to the wall or bring the wall down to you?
Quarryman - 21 Sep 2009
It is in the quarry. It is lucky the wall did not come down on him...
It does have some enhancements.
Jeff M - 21 Sep 2009
Init funny that when someone stuck artificial holds on the quarry rock they were scorned in general but 'enhance' a quarry face to make a few new holds and you seem to have a legitimate new route. Is there anyone putting up new lines that are not chipping?
bored - 22 Sep 2009
who let the jeff out of his box.........
Emil - 22 Sep 2009
Anchor bolts replaced today.
For Jeff, Steve et al - yes it is chipped, though originally not by me. I did make some enhancements myself, if only to make it climable. Quarry rock unfortunately doesnt really lend itself to harder routes, either being blank, poor quality or both. You'll find just about every route in Mountain or Stathmas quarry over grade 24 will be chipped, drilled, comfortised or glue-reinforced to some extent.
Have a go - I think you'll find it a great route that is spot on for the terrain...
Jeff M - 24 Sep 2009
Emil I am not saying it will not be a worthwhile route, probably really nice, just my personal opinion that chipping and carrots (I have climbed nice climbs with both) should remain in the past.
You "enhanced" the climb to make it climbable, are you saying that no one could have done it as it was? or you have made it just easy enough for you?
maybe a redundant arguement seeing as chippers will continue to chip but I will continue to make it none the less.
owen - 24 Sep 2009
yewww emil, choad bandit! good to see you're still charging. hopefully i'll catch you over summer if you're around
Chipping is fer everyone - 25 Sep 2009
S'funny that chipping only goes one way. If yer so hot and can do the climb so easily why not make it a little harder. Round off those sharp edges, fill in those liddle pockets. They were probably chipped anyway. Reverse chippin is the new black.
Richard - 25 Sep 2009
looking forward to Jeff's sucessful ascent of a reverse chipped and authentically restored Choad Warrior.
Jeff M - 28 Sep 2009
I tell you what, you restore it to its origional condition and I will give it a go
oh wait you can't can you...
pete - 29 Sep 2009
so jeff you're a black and white man hey? we'll put aside the fact that it's a man-made, QUARRY hell-hole for now.
Would you prefer to walk into the quarry and only have a handfull of 17s and a whole swathe of blank faces? Do you protest because you think that one day, maybe someone will pad their way up those crumbling and mirror-like cliffs?
No sweet-pea? No urban ethics? No star-wars? No chips and dips? You are a prefect man in an imperfect world jeff... Maybe you have such steely ethics that you dont climb these routes anyway.
Definition - 29 Sep 2009
Quarry : very Big chip
Jeff M - 29 Sep 2009
What would happen if I was a person not able or comfortable to push myself up the high grades, however there is a lack of well bolted low grade routes, would it be acceptable if I went to any of the "man made, Quarry hell holes" around Perth (or anywhere else in WA) and provided it not interfere with any other routes I can chip, drill and make the rock to submit to my will and put up a nice big, juggy ladder that suits me to a T. Maybe some one with more ability could climb it in a year or ten or never but now we'll never know eh?
It is good that people are out putting up new routes, this one has been chipped to a 26, what if someone around here could have climbed as it was first chipped at 30ish? or someone else got to it before emil and chipped it to a 20ish?
My ethics are that I do not chip, quarry or not, we do not have much rock over here and I feel people should climb harder not make the rock easier.
2 cents - 30 Sep 2009
Why cant everyone just get along. Sit around the campfire. Sing some songs that kind of thing =p haha i doubt it
Mark - 30 Sep 2009
Jeff, I and many others would encourage you to get out to a quarry and manufacture and bolt a nice grade 20 or lower, if you have the time and energy to do it. It would create a great climb which I'm sure many would enjoy.
The thing is Jeff, climbing in WA quarries is a unique experience and the ethics associated with climbing and developing new routes in them are far from black and white. Every climbing area has its own set of ethics which you personally may not agree with, however as a new route developer as long as you respect those ethics and the histroy of the area I see no problem with chipping to create a climb that challenges you and hopefully those that climb it in the future. It is not about the grade it is about the experience you get from bolting a climb, climbing it then seeing others have a go as well.
I personnaly have no issues with chipping in the quarries, I do have an issue with chipping naturally formed rock. This is my ethical view. Correct? Who knows and does anyone really care what my ethical stand point is, probably not. But I believe as long as I, and others respect the ethics that over time have been formed for an area we are as close as possible to climbing nivarna...
steve k - 1 Oct 2009
chippings shit ! does anyone know if Cranial Void 27 is manufactured ? looks like a sick route.
chris - 1 Oct 2009
fraid so steve. there are lots of awesome chipped routes. better than a lot of blank faces. free your mind
chris - 6 Oct 2009
wow, as a climber who has spent a lot of time over east and os i cant believe that this discussion is actually still going on. lets add it to the day light saving argument and bring wa even further into the dark ages. quite amusing! get over it guys, its a quarry. have many of you even done the route? i have and its quite good. jeff, i will give you a catch on it, if you can find your boots under the egotistical mound of dust gathering on your old, unused but ethical gear...
Jeff M - 6 Oct 2009
Egotistical? probably
Ethical? you bet
gear unused? Sorry mate it gets used all the time, probably more than most peoples and though some of it is old, a lot of it is new and shiny(ish) too.
Logan - 7 Oct 2009
Anyone mind if we took one more layer off all the walls and chipped some new routes? I am bored with the old ones. Will head out at some stage for E's route though.
josh n - 8 Oct 2009
look mate chipping is weak, if you cant get up it wait for someone who can or simply just train harder.
Kris - 8 Oct 2009
Josh et al,
The quary was one massive chip. Free for all i say. It is a quarry so who gives a rats? No chipping / gluing on natural rock though.
Wicked
Jeff M - 9 Oct 2009
Wow and another chipped route up skywalker wall too, you guys are amazing, I really hope the higher chipped holds do not affect the traverse under the roof
Richard - 9 Oct 2009
yes, saw that from a distance. Thought they'd just removed loose flakes for a colourful effect. Bit blatent if it's chipping. Awful lot of hangers.
CAWA geezer - 9 Oct 2009
HUMPH chipped hard routes HURRR too many bolts BRRAHH back in my day WURRR kids these days HURRAW where did I leave my hexes DURRAH not enough carrots I say BRRAPP when i were younger i would have shown these chippers a thing or two RASM SNASM Mumble mramsnss....
steve k - 9 Oct 2009
its a quarry - one massive chip, free for all eh. sweet - wheres that can of spraypaint ? might do some grafitti. just think of untouched walls i could access with a rope ;( and who gives a rats arse eh :/ ? um ? we do !
Kris - 12 Oct 2009
Steve K,
You have your opinion I have mine.
Enjoy climbing unchipped routes somewhere
Phillip - 12 Oct 2009
I once asked a manager at DEC about chipping in DEC-managed quarries, pointing out that these are 'artificial' rockfaces. Their reply was...
"Conservation and Land Management Regulations 2002
35A. Quarrying, removing or disturbing soil etc.
(1) A person must not, without lawful authority, disturb or remove leaf mould, rotting vegetation, humus, soil, stone or gravel on or in CALM land. Penalty: $2 000.
37. Damage to property
(1) A person must not, without lawful authority -
(a) post, stick, stamp, stencil or otherwise affix any notice, handbill, placard, advertisement, paper or other document on or to any thing or structure that is part of the landscape or property on CALM land; or
(b) write, draw or paint on or deface any thing or structure that is part of the landscape or property on CALM land. Penalty: $500."
So, it's a $500 or $2,000 fine for chipping at MQ, depending on what they feel like.
Richard - 12 Oct 2009
Sounds like a fine for bolting too.
Phillip - 12 Oct 2009
Yes, for bolting too. DEC said that technically speaking, formal written permission is required to bolt on DEC managed land, but that provided the bolts are put in correctly and 'appropriately' (minimal visual impact; with regard to cultural, historical, environmental etc etc sensitivities; and local requirements as set by the area manager) they are happy to turn a blind eye to bolting.
ed nepia - 12 Oct 2009
thanks for the legalise Philip, but whats the point of pointing that out?
Are you suggesting that folks get fined for chipping or bolting in the quarrys?
Goyder - 12 Oct 2009
Is cranial void chipped?? Was that a joke post??
If the quarry's werent chipped we would all be lining up to climb on that steep goat track playboy...
It should be noted that Emil replaced the hold that broke from Cranial Void after discussing the way the climb used to be with some of those that had climbed it previously. The route hadnt had an ascent since the hold had broken (numerous years)... The route has seen regular traffic since and thanks to Emil it is now enjoyed as it was when it was first 'augmented' with a glue on.
At least we have some people willing to get out there and add to the WA climbing environment, developing (and rebolting old routes..) new climbs. (eg. I think Emil was the one who put a lower bolt on Hang Ten to make it safer for the rest of us).
Happy to see discussion but would prefer those like me who simply leech off others routes and hard work be constructive rather than just dish out an 'anonymous' diatribe of ethics on what not to do?
Whilst not a black and white subject we must not let bureaucracy go crazy and a certain amount of artistic licence needs to be used....its a quarry...Good job Emil.
PS Phillip wtf??
Phillip - 13 Oct 2009
Some people, such as Kris have the opinion that "The quary was one massive chip. Free for all i say. It is a quarry so who gives a rats?"
Well, DEC does.
People can of course hold whatever opinion they like, but since DEC takes the view that chipping in national parks and DEC mananged land is illegal, their opinions don't really mean much.
All this ranting and raving between the pro- and anti-chippers seems a bit pointless to me.
George - 13 Oct 2009
I am in disbelief that this crap thread is still going!!!!!.
You guys arguing the toss over too chip or not too chip SERIOUSLY need too get out more.(yes that definately includes you Jeff!!).
I have been on CW and think it is a well thought out route and is a great addition to the quarry.End of story!!
Why the insessant chest puffing and brain baffling.WTF!!!. We all are well aware of DEC's point of view and to that matter Jeff's as well. Nobody gives a toss. Have a play and enjoy.
g
Joe - 13 Oct 2009
Thanks for keeping the thread going, George. Threads don't have to be meaningful, just slightly more interesting than work. BTW d'you know anything about the new route on Skywalker wall?
MArk - 13 Oct 2009
I know a bit about the route on Skywalker as I recently bolted it.
I have been looking at the line for a while now as it looks like a powerful line up the main face with a great finish up premature evacuation.
Skywalker has changed considerably now that the block has dropped out and I cleaned it and pried the 2 flakes off under the roof. When I chipped it I was very mindful of not adding to Skywalker (hence why there is no bolt in the roof as this can be protected naturally). I personally don't think any of chipped crimps towards the top of the lower wall add anything or lower the grade of Skywalker because:
1. They will be too low to use as feet and are of no use as hands on the route
2. They are drilled in and if you have climbed on drilled in holds you will know this does not really give anything for the feet.
3. There are heaps of better foot holds in the general area that are naturally occuring now the flakes have been removed.
However if I have inadventantly ditracted from skywalker in any way I will reinstate it with crushed quarry rock and aredilte.
The number of hangers is always hard when bolting a new route especially when you manufacturing it as there are no natural breaks / stances to put the clip. However it was bolted to ensure:
1. you get enough protection to ensure you don't deck / hit the side wall at the start of star wars.
2. Get a bit of exposure running it out through the crux.
3. can use the bolts to work it
As for the climb it is still a closed project and no grade has been confirmed.
If you have any question or comments come and talk to me in person as I would much rather put a face to the name. I climb at Rockface on Tue/Thur and try to get out on the weekends.
Richard - 14 Oct 2009
The hangers are a good advertisement for low visibility glue-in hex-heads. Though at >25 probably unavoidable. If the anti-chippers are sincere they’ll erase the route. Otherwise it’s all alright then. All you need is a gruff voice.
chris - 14 Oct 2009
bahahahahahahahahahahahahhahahahahahahaha, why don't all those anti chipping, anti glue on, anti bolts go sell their gear and buy golf clubs. at least then you will be as lame as your arguments. get out there, pull on or shut the hell up. there are a handful of guys in perth trying to push wa's climbing and all you guys want to do is drag it down. good on the guys out there putting up new lines in what appears to be a very anti climbing state.
Richard - 14 Oct 2009
or a shrill one
Perth - 14 Oct 2009
Thats it mate. WA = Wait a while. Gee daylight savings woulda been nice this summer but we quickly got rid of that 2 didnt we. Chip away
Boganville - 15 Oct 2009
chipping = daylight saving
deep
Jeff M - 16 Oct 2009
Lets see...
George you say end of story, why? are you so all powerful that your word is law? and if no one gives a toss and you are in disbelief that the thread is still going why did you bother to add your 2 cents worth?
Richard I generally won't erase a climb because that would alter the rock too, though if a chipped route interferes with an existing route to the extent of making it easier I will.
Chris I am not anti climbing, in fact I love it and I can turn a blind eye here and there for the odd enhancement, but if I wanted to see a gym climb I would go to a gym.
and Mark, If you can put your finger(s) in a drilled or chipped hold, you can get friction for your toe if not put your toe in it. Also how are the 'better footholds' naturally occuring if they were created by you removing flakes?
Anyhoo, have a great weekend
chris - 17 Oct 2009
hi jeff
i am out at work at the moment, but when i get back we should go for a drive around the perth crags and you can show me all the classic routes that are totally natural. i will pick you up, we can drive around the block then i will drop you off cause i don't think there would be any point driving any further. catch ya in the gym.
Ross - 19 Oct 2009
It has all been said before so I will not repeat the chipping arguments. But Mark mentions that he would mix quarry rock with araldite to repair any excesses: this is not necessary. At Bunnings you can buy a "glue stick" which consists of 2 parts of epoxy. One part is in the core, the other one is in the outer. You simply rip off a bit of the stick and hand-knead the two parts together then hand-stick it wherever as a filler. It is very simple and almost no mess, the glue stick comes in a range of colours to match the rock. So repairs are easy. I have used it to plug up some old carrot holes at Churchman's a few years ago.
MArk - 19 Oct 2009
Thanks for that Ross. Did you end up making an ascent of SW last week?
George - 20 Oct 2009
Jeff, Firstly no my word is certainly not law!, but it definitely has some actions and effort standing behind it!!!.
Its pretty easy to be a bottom feeder with lots of unhelpful hot air, than a greatful one who adds value to the climbing community. The reason i add my 2 cents worth is because i find it funny that people like your self take such moral high grounds on topics that are so rare and unique.
" I can turn a blind eye here and there for the odd ENHANCEMENT",
"but 'ENHANCE' a quarry face to make a few new holds and you SEEM to have a legitimate new route"
I thought you could turn a blind eye?!!!!
Ethical: you bet??
high ground or low ground???not sure i understand where your coming from.Its either accepted or not, there is no option to sit on the fence and crap on whichever side suits you at the time!!. But as you said it is probably just a redundant argument anyway!.
Peace
g
Jeff m - 22 Oct 2009
Sorry George maybe this bottom feeder did not explain his point of view simply enough for you. Straight up I do not like the way these new drilled, chipped, glued, ergonomic and finger friendly routes seem to be popping up all over the place. Have a look at Skywalker wall, that new route is ugly as hell, possibly the worst chipping I have seen since gracetown, fully manufactured and possibly interfering with an existing classic. I think this sort of outdoor gym climb is just wrong. I do say I can turn a blind eye as though I do not agree with it older classic lines such as Urban ethics and such have slightly enhanced holds here or there (not great but doesn't stand out like dogs balls). You guys may say it is a quarry and man made but the rock is not, it is rock. You can call me all the names you want but my opinion is what it is. and chris yes the drive would only be around a small block as most of the quarries are close together. We could go look at climbs such as city limits, playboy, penthouse,split personality, mullup, sylvia, barren awakenings, the force, vader, skywalker, powerplay, and plenty more...and thats only the first quarry.
Love Jeff
PLEASE - 22 Oct 2009
PLEASE! PLEASE webmaster close this thread!
Finish it - 22 Oct 2009
Okay i am all for conversation and debate. But hasnt everyones point been made. Chip or not. Its your choice. Now lets talk about something else please =)
Kris - 23 Oct 2009
C'mon climbers! Lets keep chipping away at this thread.....we have a long way to go before we beat the record thread "Carrots"
Mint
Peace and Love - 23 Oct 2009
We attack Jeff not so much because he’s a purist, but for his infuriatingly sarcastic tone. George on the other hand tries hard to stand firmly on both sides of the fence which results in some entertaining syntax.
The key is Phillips point way above. That what we do, bolting chipping chopping, has very little legal standing. The way things are is determined by individual initiative. Words are political tools to get people to do what we want them to do at no cost to ourselves. If chipped climbs are not removed then they are accepted. The people that have had a powerful influence on the way things are right now are the ones who’ve done something. Whether you agree with them or not George and Woodman have changed the nature of many badly decayed routes and brought a new consumer-friendly standard to quarry climbing. Their one weakness seems to be they want people to like them. The glue-in hexhead crowd has fought back with excellent soundly bolted lines, maintaining the credibility and popularity of this style of bolting. Whoever removed the last bashin carrot line stopped the steady production of bashin classics (though there are still lines going up, but you won’t read about them here). In their time the bashin climbers expanded Perth climbing amazingly. Establishing vast numbers of high quality routes. All change is the result of action. Threads like this are a great way to practice creative writing.
Darren - 24 Oct 2009
Jeff I would like to climb something over grade 22 but thanks for pointing out some of the more natural lines.. I'll let grandma know which ones aren't manufactured..
Were-Rabbit - 24 Oct 2009
Bounce... Bounce... Bounce... Ahhhhhh... Carrots! Yum!
George - 24 Oct 2009
I love these historic sub-groups of First ascentionists /Bolters/aficionados....whatever!. That certain members of the climbing fraternity are always banging on about. "Glued in Hex head crew" and "Bashin Legends" sounding more like mixed netball teams, than cheapskate rap-bolting bashers!:)(thats not a real dig at rap-bolting,as i fall in that catagory....just not a cheapskate!!).
"credibility and popularity of this style of bolting" , CLASSIC!. This probably should have finished with.....amongst the all conquering mixed netball team of "the GIMB lovers".
"bashin classics"Isnt that a oximoron?!
and" Establishing vast numbers of high quality routes"...OK credit where credit is due, but seriously!. I admire the drive and effort, but not the bolting.
We could probably introduce another netball team right now "the basher sect". They definately dont bolt and are trying to be more on the purist end of the scale, but they have this romantic infatuation with the art of bashin one in and its likeness to ye oldie days of the mighty piton(the tradmans bolt!!).
AS for creating a consumer friendly crag. I like to think of it more in terms of giving people the option to climb routes with the same quality of bolts the all conquering FA had(admittedly much better in this cas!). Instead of putting old bolting practices on a pedestal and whispering in hushed tones about how dicey the bolts on said route are and how it "has" BECOME a reputation route.
I can only really put it down to Contrived adventure. these routes really arent bold in the true sense and there reputations are only in their Western Australian lunch boxes......but hey gotta love a bit of bolt banta!!!!!.
peace ......and love
G
P&L - 26 Oct 2009
To start with a mixed netball team is a great place to meet toned women. Secondly this thread’s standard of writing is deteriorating into moralising soap opera. George is becoming incomprehensible again. Through sweat and effort he’s had a huge impact on local quarry climbing. But he’s still obsessed with what people think. Does he want us to vote for him or what.
And that rabbit, maybe it can be helpful in pruning some routes. Technical question: How doyou get out glue in hex heads? Pees are easy. Even embedded ones. Just hammer them round till they snap or the glue fails. Bashins are very hard, and glue-in hexes it seems, have to be cut. The only pull-out tests I heard about involved a steel cable and a 4x4. That was a sandstone area and all it found was that the rock broke before the glue. Cutting takes several minutes. So what’s the easy method? Maybe a custom made flogging spanner.
Lots and lots of peaceful passive-aggressive love !!!!!
Logan - 26 Oct 2009
Awsome thread! At least it shows Perth has a very passionate climbers willing to squabble over the little we have. I am so bored at work right now :)I got on CW the other day and i couldnt climb it the way i could see it was designed to be climbed (due to reach)but i could still find ways to do all the moves and it was a fun worthwhile route. It was definetely set better (for me) than cranial as i cant do a few moves on that due to balancy reaches. Maybe next route set could have a few foot jibs to help the short in stature? Could they be green? I like that colour.
Emil, nice work, if you want to rebolt properly Space Monkey then go ahead. Its an awsome route that cleaned up would get some traffic. Fair bit harder than CW (2-3 grades. Unfortunately that wall (not city limits) was bolted by some impressionable 15-16? year olds who thought that climbs had to be scary runout to be a test piece. Did i mention they hadnt bolted much if anything before? Anyway SM is a sick route for those that wish to discover it.
Anyway i am off to climb something natural outside of the quarry!
George - 26 Oct 2009
I would agree that my alter ego "Eugene" definately raised his rather incomprehensible head again......a little bit too much passion perhaps :-).
As for wanting votes and friends!?, not real sure what your on about, just calling it how i see it. Maybe i need a bit of anonymous posters therapy!?:).
As for getting out GIMBs:not real hard, same as carrots. appropriate socket with large bar attachment and twist away.
As for pulling out pees, they might be easy if they are sticking out and not recessed(just put large socket bar through and twist). But comparing a well recessed P and a GIMB, the P is miles harder, without a doubt. especially if the GIMB has not been chisel edged at the end. Thread definately adds strength in an outward pull, but is still easy to twist out.
Peter T - 27 Oct 2009
I haven't contributed to this thread yet, and I think I ought to as it's been going on so long. So here goes..... hi to anyone that knows me!
Peter
Dinah - 27 Oct 2009
I haven't contributed either and I can see it's welly good fun so hi Peter T!! Whatapity Were Rabbit hasn't got run over by a truck or infested by one of those human concocted bunny genocide virus's.
Emil - 8 Nov 2009
Consensus is that CW is probably 27. If anyone strenuously objects to that grade, please come have a chat or post here...
ed nepia - 9 Nov 2009
well actually i always found 27 quite strenuous ...
STFU - 11 Nov 2009
So much whining, so little climbing. STFU and go climb a rock ya whinging freakin babies. (Jeff or God as he qould like to think)
jobro - 10 May 2010
yo
sorry to wake a sleeping giant, but I only just saw this thread :)
don't care to get into the chipping debate, but I was just a bit confused about the dealio with the missing hold on Cranial Void....Goyder said it hadn't been climbed w out the hold, but I watched Tim Djerkins (barely 16 at the time) climb that route back in 2004....had the hold been ripped off at that point? I can't remember? anyone know? I'm just curious....
Richard W - 10 May 2010
Latest info is that myself and Nick cleaned it up a little using a chisel to clear away some loose crap and for what I remember there is some little edges near the top that make it doable without the glue on hold. Nick redpointed it a couple of years ago! Is that how you remember it Nick?