Climbing Talk
Grading the climb...
Started by Mark
·
·
52 replies
Archived thread
Replies are closed. Some details, such as access rules and gate codes, may be out of date.
Mark - 16 May 2005
Should it be for the onsight? Of course it should.
I have spoken with a few of Perth's "hardmen" and questioned their thoughts on if a climb should be graded for the onsight or the redpoint. I am puzzled with their response that a climb should be graded for the redpoint. Now this may be the case if you have worked and then climbed a route to death, as your body becomes used to the moves, you become fitter and the climb become wired, you know the rests, you now the best body position etc… But for those that attempt a climb as an onsight, (which I feel is the most satisfying send) should it still not be graded for the onsight?
Logan - 16 May 2005
I agree with those so called "hardmen". A route should be graded for the redpoint. Many times someone works up to a grade until they tick the route or boulder problem. At this stage they are fitter and stronger and climbing the grade. The holds have not got any bigger, no magic rests have appeared. The fact that they have knowledge of the route helps them but the fact they have the potential to climb that grade is there. Onsighting simply means you have the potential to climb several grades harder if you had the patience to put in the time and effort to work a route. Onsighting is a good feeling but not as good as ticking a route above your limit that you have put time and effort into, a route that becomes personal.
Emil - 16 May 2005
I feel that grading a route is a "complex decision-making matrix" that is not as simple as calling it an onsight or even red-point grade. I am willing to argue though.
The point I would like to make with Mark is if what he says is true I will concede that "Fun, Love and Joy" at Wallcliff is 23 to onsight (but certainly not 24).
Anon - 16 May 2005
It's about time we get some consitancy in grades of around WA. Looking at 24's...
Heavy Petting - Kalbarri
Fuck the law - Kalbarri
Fun love and Joy - Wallclife
Hang Ten - Mt Quarry
Heavy Metal - Willy
Turbo Crack - Hardy Rd
There is at least 2 grade differences between some of these... What are the thoughts of a blanket regrading of WA climbs to get them in perspective not only with the rest of WA but the rest of Australia?
Anon 2 - 16 May 2005
Gotta disagree with you Logan (and no disrespect)- you're not 'fitter and stronger' when you finally manage to redpoint a project- you've just memorised the moves! There is a concept known as muscle memory and that is what has happened.
I'd much rather climbs be graded at the level they are when onsighting (cos I hate working things as projects!) but as long as we're consistent I don't really mind!
Emil - 16 May 2005
Ooooh, I love this subject. Here's what i think:
Heavy Petting - Kalbarri - 22
Fuck the law - Kalbarri - (no comment havnt done it for ages)
Fun love and Joy - Wallclife - 22/23
Hang Ten - Mt Quarry - 23
Heavy Metal - Willys - 23
Turbo Crack - Hardy Rd - 24 if your fingers are less than 1.5cm in girth, 25 if greater.
Thrutching the Bison - Kalbarri - 22
Kyle - Wallcliff - 21
Llama arete - Hardy Rd - Solid 23 esp O/S
Mark - 16 May 2005
Geeze Emil bit harsh there. Killing a few people's first grade 24 lead and suggesting it maybe only 22? (ref - fun love and joy).
While we are at it... Chain reaction needs a few grades chopped as well.
And what would you grade the 23 (Belt Fed)you struggled on at Pinjarra?
Logan - 16 May 2005
Dear Anon2. Rather than training in a gym all the time (which does help you improve) it is possible to get on routes which are above your level and by working them improve your grip strength, body tension and technique. I am well aware of muscle memory which does play a part in a redpoint of a worked route and also in training such as the few who do laps on cardiofunk at Mt Quarry. This is a grade 29 which is easily lapped by those that do not onsight 29 but the training with the use of muscle memory is great for power endurance. From my experience you are definetely fitter and stronger when you finally get the route.
As for Emils grading - Very Harsh - but maybe this critcism is what some routes need.
ben - 16 May 2005
I stopped caring about grades a while ago. The less I care about grades the more I enjoy climbing and the better I climb. I think that's irony.
Next time you go climbing cross out the grades in the guidebook and just think about how much you enjoyed the climb. The grade is no measure of the quality of the climb or the person who climbs it. OOOh.
Neil - 16 May 2005
I agree with Emil - the grade depends on a bit more than whether its an onsight or a redpoint, but in general grading based on a redpoint is correct IMO.
Heavy Petting - 22
Fuck the law - easy 25
Fun love and Joy - Wallclife - 23
Hang Ten - Mt Quarry - 24
Heavy Metal - straightforward 24
Turbo Crack - hard 24.
Thrutching the Bison - 22
Kyle - 21ish
Llama arete - Solid 23
These kind of issues make climbing so interesting. If all gr23's felt the same then that would take a fair bit of the attraction away from climbing. Likewise, different climbers will all have different opinons wrt what grade it is. The actual grade the climb is given should be a rough concensus of this.
Emil - 16 May 2005
ok, ok I could go to 23 for FL+J but that's my final offer. And Mark, the reason that it is folks' first 24 is because it's really 23!As for your salacious comment about that contrivance at Pinjarra, you're right, maybe after it's finished exfoliating, it may be worth climbing. Ha Ha
Jamie - 16 May 2005
A grade is based on a general concensus that a climbis of a similar difficulty of another climb in a similar style.
Personally grades can be used as a benchmark for personal growth and achievement...to measure progress and also as a guide....if for example you climb grade 20 you can walk up to other grade 20 climbs and should have a fair amount of sucess.
As far as grading for redpoint or onsight...does it really matter...it doesnt change the difficulty of the climb...it only shows the appreximate relation of the difficulty of that climb in relation to other climb of a similar grade..whether the climb is graded 22 or 24 the difficulty of that particular climb wont change.
One final note there will always be differing opinions of how difficult a climb is and give or take a grade or two its really academic...depending on the style of the climb (slab, face, overhang, crack) and how you are performing on the day you may find a climb harder or easier or about right to the given grade.
So just leave it alone or if a climb is way out adjust it by common consensus.
Glenn - 16 May 2005
Greetings All:
My understanding is the Ewbank grading system was defined for the "onsight leader". If you are using any other definition you are not using the australian grading system.
The system was designed to take into account gear placement, route (and hold) finding, and fear factors.
I dont see how anyone can seriously argue that climbs dont get easier after on multiple attempts?
Neil - 17 May 2005
What about White Witches on the Cross at Peak Head ? (c/w vulcan grip!)
I wonder if anyone has onsighted Llama Arete..... That climb has also benefited from a fair bit of ethic sculpting. However, without the glue and sculpting the climb wouldn't be there....
I'm pretty sure Ewbank is the redpoint grade. Onsight is too variable and too dependant on how you do the moves.
Mark - 17 May 2005
One of Perth's "hardmen" OS Larma Arete 2 weeks ago. A very solid lead.
As to Emils comments about Pinjarra --- Dry your eyes...
Emil - 17 May 2005
I think i had something in my eye. must have been the hellacious bush-bash.
Toc - 17 May 2005
I wondered if I should even comment on this, but anyway here goes. Every one of the small number of climbs I've put up has been a natural onsight, and only one of them have I repeated. Every grade I gave was subject to revision from further ascents from other people particularly the seconder who probably was in a better position to have a clearer think about it than me.
From a grading point of view does it matter if you onsite or redpoint? "All"? a redpoint means is you've practised the climb, but the degree of difficulty of the climb doesn't vary. So maybe when grading from an onsite perspective you need to sit back, think about it and try and remove from your thoughts how much more difficult it was because you didn't know what the hell was coming up next. So grading from a redpoint perspective doesn't make the climb itself, harder or easier, but hopefully will produce a more accurate grade. Anyway aren't all grades provisional and waiting for a consensus from further ascents, at least initially?
So I'd be happy to have open slather on West Australian grades, because some of them could probably be adjusted. (not that I can comment on the climbs you guys are talking about, because I don't climb that hard)
Cheers all.
Neil - 17 May 2005
Did any of the "hardmen" who visted Llama Rock try the awkward crack left of Turbo Crack ? There are 20's then there are 20's !
The project (belay bolts on top) on the smooth steep wall right of the chasm at Llama Rock has been top roped cleanly and is worth a go too.
Also, the Fedayn at Connoisseur Rocks is worth a go if you can do laps on Turbo Crack.
Mark - 17 May 2005
"Hardmen" of perth OS'ed the crack to the left of Turbo Crack. I am the first to admit, I was thoroughly spanked. Definitely a tough 20/21 - belt, braces and flannelette blue collar climbing.
Emil - 17 May 2005
Neil - Do you happen to know if the RHS of the arete that is opposite the thin 18 slab at Llama has been done? There is a 17-18 slab/arete climb on the LHS of it, but the RHS has a thin crack and carrot bolt near the top. Havnt seen any mention of it anywhere. Looks like it would go mostly on gear and be 22-24ish.
We top-roped the proj you mentioned clean although climbing the tree made us cry. The flake at the top creaked ominously....
Neil - 17 May 2005
Hmmm. Not sure exactly what route you are refering too. I'd say it has been done if there is a bolt there. Although, it may have been done as an easier, indirect variant as I don't remember any routes around the 22-24 mark.
What do you think of Turbo Crack and Llama Arete ? I reckon they are 2 of the better routes on granite boulders near Perth. It's a shame there weren't a few more routes like these.... equaly so, pity the project line didn't have a hold or 2 extra down low to make the tree free start a more reasonable grade :(.
That reminds me - there is a nice route at Upper Darlington that's also 1 hold short of being an instant classic. it has been done, but it's very height dependant.
ross_oman - 17 May 2005
Here I am, sitting in Oman, 40C outside, so jelaous you guys are climbing. At least I can write...
I put up some climbs around Perth, I always tried to grade for onsight but this is a hopeless task. Imagine this: I spot a line, rap it, clean it, bolt it, dog it, then get it. By then I know every hold and move pretty well. So now I try to step back and ask myself "how hard is this for someone who is not familiar with this?" So I tend to have a stab and then change opinion based on feed back. (I do try to climb any natural trad routes on sight.) Another thing is that I am 190 cm tall, weigh 88kg and have +3" ape factor but also a weak grip (can't boulder for shit). So how is the same route going to feel to someone who is 155cm, 50kg...etc. Here lies the problem.
And not only that, climbs vary so much, I mean almost anyone can train up to a 24 Kalbarri route but a 24 granite slab (think Ron's efforts at Mt Cuthbert). So the grading system accuracy is +/-1 grade even if the rock/cliff is similar (depending on who grades it) and comparing grades across granite and sandstone and dolomite and limestone and cracks and slabs and overhangs.....well, you see what I mean.
To me the purpose of the grade is to tell the climber if this climb is for them, i.e. if you lead 18 then you don't want to be on runout 24. The rest is detail, but still worth giving opinions. Grades do change and guidebooks get updated.
I have climbed around the world and found that 24 is 5.11d and 7a, just like most guidebook tables say (not Shane's guidebooks, the tables in those are hopeless). So Perth is not undergraded or requiring a blanket regrade. When I did the last Perth guidebook I asked people for comments on grades and anything and got maybe 20 comments, so there were no strong feelings about that then.
End of lunch break. Enjoy climbing, lucky scumbags.
Ross
Glenn - 17 May 2005
Hi All:
Somewhere in my pile of climbing junk I have Ewbanks original article on climbing grades - I might dig it out sometime....
I am pretty sure the grading system was developed for an onsight leader (assumes absolutely no knowledge of the climb other than what you can see from the ground); the original system was ment to include all factors, including poor gear etc.
I am sorry to say that this means many of you need to lower your claims by around 4 grades
:-)
either that or convert to the US system...
Emil - 18 May 2005
Nice one Ross, i agree 24 is 5.11d and 7a (depending on the area). Sorry to harp on about this one, but there is no way that FL+J or Heavy Metal would get 11d.
Seeing as though youre over there - have you climbed at Wadi Rum in Jordan yet?
Neil - 18 May 2005
Would you give Orestes 24 ?
Crawling from the Wreckage 23 ?
3rd pitch of Stranger in a Strange Land = 18 ??? (Nostromo ?)
so many more..... semantics really.
As ben said, it doesn't really matter as long as you're having fun.
Emil - 18 May 2005
Orestes is a bargain at 24. 23 more like it. Crawling from the wreckage was regraded to 20 in the latest select guide, though i would say 21/2 esp if youre taller. Stanger in a Strange Land - is that the one at Peak Head? Havnt done it i dont think..
For a bit of perspective on 24 consider:
Endless Pitch, Fingernickin' and Robbin Hood at Moonarie.
Paladin, Blue Eyed and Blonde, Die Loaded at Araps or the top pitch of World Party on Taipan.
No comparison really.
Ben's point is valid that we shouldnt get wrapped up in grades, but we all still use them to whatever extent is meaningful to us. Its a yardstick and we are conferring to ensure all our sticks are the same legnth is all.
remember though its not the legnth of the yardstick that matters....
Neil - 18 May 2005
Endless Pitch makes most 24's look pretty average !
Araps 24's can be pretty serious (Orestes exlcuded).
Mark - 18 May 2005
I have spoken with Emil about his harsh re grading of several of WA’s 23/24/25's. But I got out my Tassie guide books last night (Where I have done a lot of my climbing) and tried to recalled most of the climbs I have done there and at Araps / Bluies / Nowra and am starting to agree with him that there are a few WA climbs that are a bit soft for the grade. There I said it. But I still believe you need to grade for the onsight so here is my 2c
Fun love and Joy - Wallclife - 23
Hang Ten - Mt Quarry - 24
Heavy Metal - Willys - 24
Turbo Crack - Hardy Rd - 24
Thrutching the Bison - Kalbarri - 22
Llama arete - Hardy Rd - 23
Chain Reaction - 22
For those that bring up the age old response to this discussion, “what do grades matter, climb for fun, enjoy the experience etc, etc, etc”. I think most people do climb for fun and they do enjoy the experience. The most memorable climbs I have done were at a much lower grades to my redpoint ability. But climbing is the most egotistical sport I can think of. Grades do matter, that’s why most? people climb. It allows you to always be striving for something better and for pushing yourself to your limits but still knowing there is room for improvement. Deliberating over the grade of a climb just gives a benchmark for oneself
ross - 18 May 2005
Me again, another lunch break....grades matter to some people, trad climbing matters to others, bouldering to other yet...whatever. There is an excellent interview with Gerard in last Western Climber (which recently reached me even here), where he talks amongst others about how MEMORABLE some climbs are (this is in response to last comment). This is a whole different issue to grades. One is quantity and other is quality. Apples and pears. But neither is "inferior" in my book: I remember "Mandela" at American Fork because it was a 5.12a redpoint and I can't climb harder. I also remember Epinephrine (5.9, Red Rocks Nevada) because it is an 8 pitch chimney (!!).
Emil - yeah Jordan, no have not visited yet; hopefully I can get there but I'm about to have 2nd kid so am temporarily stuffed. But life is long...
I may write an article on climbing in Oman, it is sort of amusing.
Logan - 19 May 2005
Ross "grades matter to some people, trad climbing matters to others, bouldering to other yet...whatever."
Are you saying that trad climbing and bouldering dont have grades? I dont think it is the style of climbing that is an issue here. Sure people do different styles some people do them all, but the chase to continually better oneself in all aspects of life let alone climbing is why we have grades so we can see our improvement. Grades isnt necesarily why we climb but it definitely keeps us in perspective of how we climb. I agree with Marks previous comments.
Matt Rosser - 19 May 2005
I find Ross’s comments on the consultative grading process puzzling. Ross and the Ethical Filter have unilaterally been downgrading my lines for years and while I respect their opinions and wish them much happiness I disagree with a number of their decisions. For example, I believe that an on sight lead of Lama Arête is 24; if an on sight lead of Karma can be openly promoted as a 24 then Lama Arête is easily 24. I also think that as an on sight Turbo Crack is 25 and that an on sight of the Shield is 24.
Jon Gregg - 20 May 2005
Hi, Ethical Filter here, as I seem to have been named.
Matt, only 2 climbs spring to mind that I have suggested should be downgraded, Llama Arete and The Shield as you've mentioned.
In both cases I looked at other similar types of climbs or ones in the same area. Llama Arete I think is not as hard as other 24 granite routes around - say Shredder at Toodyay or your desperate 24 at Shark Rock. Three of the posts above reckon Llama Arete is 23.
The Shield at Mtn Quarry I benchmarked against Hang Ten, which I think is solid 24 and a bit harder.
As for Karma, it took me a few goes before I got it and at the time I was thinking that maybe it should be 23. If you took the crux off it and put it on a short Perth granite route then it would probably only rate around 22/23. Others reckon it should remain at 24 (it was originally graded 25!).
IMO grades should be based on redpoint. Although some climbs are notoriously hard to onsight, the climb is still the same no matter how many goes it takes. Onsight will always be the best type of ascent and the most rewarding so just be happy with the extra prestige when bragging about your onsight. I do!
Mark - 20 May 2005
There has been a bit of discussion about the route Larma Arete and in keeping with the theme of this post onsight vs redpoint I pose this question. For a climb that is 2/3 natural 1/3 bolted surely the climb must be graded for the onsight? You do not find many people, stripping the placed gear then replacing the gear for the redpoint (especially when it is relatively short and 1 of the placements could only be described as OK). Is it not more common to redpoint on the preplaced gear? Redpointing on preplaced gear (natural) must make the perceived grade of the climb easier. There is no hanging around fiddling for the gear or making the placement. This is why I think there is always 1 to 1 ½ grade difference between natural and sport routes, with natural being harder. Surely the grade of the climb must take into account the additional difficulty of selecting the gear, placing the gear, conditions, exposure etc. An example is Kachoong (Araps) where the grade is given an additional 1-2 points for the manky pitons and the exposure… Thoughts…
Matt Rosser - 20 May 2005
I would not use Hang Ten as a guide in grading a quarry 24. This climb has been worn out. All its good original holds are only a shadow of their former glory: in the halcyon days of our youth, a bright period when Ron first walked the quarry floor, we would solo Hang Ten blind folded at the end of a long day.
In grading 24 in the quarry Star Wars and Month of Sundays are better guides. I believe that with these two lines in mind the Shield is 24 on sight.
Shredder is now missing a couple of low holds that were present when it was originally graded and to my mind the line is now a full grade harder.
Jamie - 21 May 2005
just while on comparing 24's, whats everyones impression of snatches and lays at churchies?
how does this stand up as a 24..?
Matt Rosser - 22 May 2005
I respectfully suggest that if you are going to change a climbs grade then talk to the person who graded the climb originally and climb it in the style that the grade intended so that an accurate opinion can form.
I graded Llama Arête 24 some time after its FA - climbed without a fall, placing all gear on lead. I discussed the grade with two very experienced climbers, my 2nd and another. I considered the grade should convey the same style to a climber armed with only his gear, the grade and a sporting sprit.
It was downgraded a week later by those who had not lead it. Unfortunately, I was not consulted.
I did the same for the Shield. However, with the Shield I climbed it with 3 separate groups (all OS) and consulted them before settling the grade at 24. It was downgraded. Again without a clean lead from the retro graders and zero consultation.
To me the message in the grade is important. The Ewbank grading system is our system and “considers exposure, technical difficulty or any combination of problems, access to protection and their placement, strenuousness and time involved in surmounting problem”. Ewbank, John ‘Grading System’ THRUTCH April 1968, pp 18-23
Retro grading from a top rope or using pre placed gear may result in a lower grade being attributed. It is easier as a more dynamic flowing style of climbing is possible. Finding your way, stoping to place gear is all part of the job and is part of the Ewbank grade.
I would still advise a climber that is heading out to do a clean lead of Llama and/or the Shield that they should be prepared to climb a Ewbank grade 24.
Ross - 22 May 2005
Hah, hah, Matt...you soloed Hang Ten blindfolded...hah, hah.... must have been the same hallowed period when I soloed Everest without oxygen, stark naked and carrying a bundle of wood for the summit bonfire! Nice one....for your info Jon graded his Turbo Crack 24, so we graded Llama Arete 23 because it is easier, as you well know because you could not do it. This is not mean to with any disrespect, you are a decent climber, but one thing I tried to do with a guidebook is to at least get the grades of climbs in one area set correct relative to each other. Emil, Neil and Mark agree with the 23 so there. Besides, you did not onsight it and neither did your climbing partner so you guys are the least qualified to have an opinion on this. I made a point about this earlier. And I upgraded your Thin Red Line in the Miniguide.
Logan - I was not implying anything. Don't read stuff into my comments. We all do whatever pleases us, that was my point. Nothing wrong with grades at all.
It's just a sport !! Lighten up. In the long run we're all dead anyway.
Ross
Jamie - 22 May 2005
isnt it funny how a sport that can foster such a good sense of community spirit amoungst climbers can also so easily turn into a slanging match full of hurt egos.
Lets stop all this crap arguing about a climb being +/- 1 grade....
lets face it unless you use the grading system to bolster your ego a grade should only be used as a guide to indicate to a climber what climbs in an area are achievable for them and as a safety measure so they dont jump on something that is way of of their depth.
Lets all just grow up and stop playing little boys with bruised egos.
John Knight - 22 May 2005
Initial grading should really be subject to change later on. An initial grade is given by one person with a particular build, particular gear, particular kind of shoes and personal strengths and weaknesses with particular climbing styles.
As an example, in a bouldering competition a year or two ago, I was easily able to do a mid 40s (bouldering comp score not standard score!) route that Ross couldn't and was struggling on a number of times. Anyone who knows Ross and anyone who knows me will know that Ross is a much better climber than I am; the only reason I could do it easily was that it fitted perfectly to my favourite methods of climbing (crimp, flag, crimp, flag.....).
And that's just covering climbing styles. Initial grading should be made in the knowledge that people are going to argue it later, where it can then be more accurate.
As an unfortunate example, Ben's bouldering guides have had some harsh criticism around Perth, where he rates it in the more universal V grading. I've heard some people say it's rubbish because some V1s are easier than V0s, and V0's supposed to be a 21, the grading seems innacurate..... all this kind of bollocks.
HE WAS RE-INVENTING THE WHEEL!
Ben's guide was a prime example of how someone was trying to introduce V grading and develop bouldering as a sport here in WA. This takes an enormous effort, and without any other real places in WA to compare to (especially WA granite), this is bound to be a very hard task with some innacuracies.
As far as I could see, Ben's motive was to do an initial grading as a general guide, get feedback, and then update it to be more accurate. Shouldn't we all approach it this way? Shouldn't we all humbly grade our climbs in the hope that people will give us feedback and we can get a general consensus?
Jumping to left field for a moment, with reagrds to onsight and redpoint, I find redpointing far more satisfying. Call me crazy, as most people are crazy for onsights, but I just find that an onsight isn't pushing my limits. A redpoint is somehting I've had to work at and endure. An onsight is a thrill; a redpoint is an overcome hurdle that really satisfies.
Matt Rosser - 24 May 2005
Respectfully, I would like to summarise my main points as I given them some consideration and I think they are getting lost:
I propose we use John Ewbank’s system and refer to his published description of what the method considers - see THRUTCH April 1968, pp 18-23
I propose we grade lines with an OS in mind and of course expect that the gear is placed on lead not pre placed.
Before grading a climb I recommend consulting other experienced climbers particularly on the better lines.
I don’t agree with climbs being published with a changed grade without consulting the FA if possible or at least other climbers (that is more than one other). I think that one or two people deciding by themselves to retrograde climbs is not best practice.
With regard to Ross’s comments my response is:
Firstly, I am confused by the comment about the Thin Red Line. The mini guide holds the original grade I posted on the CAWA site - there was no regrade.
Secondly, you are right I did try very hard to get the FA of what was to become Turbo Crack. My best result was three days before the line was claimed. On my first attempt I fell and while I pulled the ropes I left a single wire in place which I clipped on the way through to the top. Because I had left a wire on the line I did not consider this to be a claimable FA. The climb was claimed a few days later.
Jess - 27 May 2005
I've just read all your replies and you know was I find most interesting? So far there are none from the girls. Us girls are often just stoked to get to the top of a difficult climb let alone worry about the grade. You guys are almost always gonna think the grading is soft because you're generally alot stronger than us and most of the time can just muscle your way up. I get the most satisfaction out of ticking a climb before my male climbing buddy does, no matter what the grade cos is shoes that us girls can achieve just as much even though what you guys think is a 21 feels like a 24 to us.
Ross - 28 May 2005
I agree with Matt in principle. I just want to highlight that grades are by consensus, but consensus takes time to develop and in the last issue of the Perth guide there were 100s of new routes. Before the next issue of the guide (nothing planned), if I am still connected with it there will be a draft copy available in the gyms and anyone is very welcome to mark it up with their opinions which will not be ignored(just like last time but last time the draft guide did not have all the routes because routes went up until the day it was published).
Jess - how about Lynn Hill on The Nose: unrepeated by any male in any similar same style? When I aided that roof pitch in '99 I could not fathom anyone freeing it; and there is about 20 pitches before that!!! And it would be incredibly powerful. I think the strength/weight ratio for women, given their lighter built, can be just the same as for men and the only reason the top males are stronger is because 10 times as many males climb at the high level then women, it seems.
Claire - 29 May 2005
Hi all,
Just having a read of this most interesting suject.GRADING! Wow, where to start. Personally I believe that grading is subject to the ability of the climbers and the style of the climb. Some people find slab easy, balance comes naturally and you can take your time assessing all the moves slowly as you go. Others find overhangs easy, nice strong moves that flow easily for them. Whatever your strength will determine what you feel the grade of a climb is.
The first ascent and the grade then determined will vary from climber to climber. Those people who are putting up routes need to consider many things. I think that there will always be varying levels of one specific grade. 24 to one person will be hard and 24 to another person will be easy. I think that the bottom line is that you have to enjoy all the climbing that you do. Make you own goals and use the grading system as an indicator of what you are in for when deciding on what climbs you could possibly do. The guides are there for us all to be able to go out and enjoy our climbing in WA. Use them as a "GUIDE"! It is not then end of the world if someone has a different opinion to you, for goodness sake get over the bitching. You sound like a bunch of girls! And that makes us look bad!
To finish up grades vary no matter what state that you climb in. No matter what grading system that you you use or no matter if you you grade on redpoint or onsight. There will always be differences in opinion and we have just got to come to a general concensus about what the grades are. Please enjoy all the climbing that you do and I hope that see you at the crag sometime.
John Knight - 29 May 2005
Have to agree with Claire and Jess here, and Jess brought up something that particularly erks me. This is probably more of a climbing gym issue, so I'll just talk about plastic for now....
I don't like grading that is partly based around (or even inconsiderate of) height. At 6 foot, I don't have any real trouble reaching the holds on most Perth climbs, but many people do. Some climbing gyms are notoriously reachy or even include a reachy section as part of a grade. Some gyms are better than others for this, and I believe training and difficulty on plastic should be based around technical difficulty, and height shouldn't really be much of an issue. So if you're a route setter, please try and keep the shorter population in mind. :)
Di - 12 Jul 2005
Back to retro-grading . . . Morning Glory at Stathams . . . . It's a 17 cos the bottom half is 15 and the top is 19 (average= 17 for those of you less mathematically inclined).
I reckon we just give it a 19 and be done with it and next time I'm swearing in four languages on it I won't feel like quite such a big girl.
God - 17 Jul 2005
Just reeelaaaxxx and trust them feet, big girl....I know yer all tense because of the slightly runout nature of the situation up there. For a real 19 try Slot Machine at Darlington or Quiver at Mt.Cuthbert (just an 18). I made those just for you. Go on...
Di - 18 Jul 2005
Run out? MG is certainly not run out! I'm referring to the technical difficulty of the moves!
And watch who you're calling a 'big girl!!'
John Knight - 18 Jul 2005
EBQ = medium height slim girl, right di? :)
Di - 18 Jul 2005
John I'm pretty sure there was an 'evil' in EBQ but you can argue that point with my mate Jon at Rockface.
Hope your tendon is improving, see you at the comp!
John Knight - 19 Jul 2005
Tendon's not too bad, been bouldering at kalamunda with ben's guide. gym plastic always injures so much more though, i think my appearance at the comp will definitely be of a helper, not of a competitor.
Jon - 19 Jul 2005
Di is a big evil bully girl who makes me boulder :) (did I see u with a harness on the other night *gasps in horror*)
though she can't do my reachy dyno'y problems hee hee hee :)
Di - 19 Jul 2005
Yeah yeah John but I only put my harness on under duress. And it probably took me many minutes to figure out how!
See ya tonight.
Ollie - 28 Sep 2005
In my opinion climbs should always been rated for on-sight as there are a lot of muli-pitch or alpine climbs where it's just impossible to check out the route and memorize it. That's why ppl usually indicate if they scored onsight or redpoint or even aided. Obviously you have to be able to score a higher graded red-point before you can on-sight the same grade. But this is part of the game as it is with protection. Again, this is not part of the grade but makes a lot of difference (traditional, heavily bolted). There are other factors like altitude, height, conditions which are not part of the grading system but which should be mentioned. I think the grade should always be as high as the hardest part of the pitch. You wouldn't grade a consistent 20m high climb different from a 3m climb even if it's much easier...