/

/

Glue existing holds?

Climbing Talk

Glue existing holds?

Started by Nat

·

·

5 replies

Archived thread

Replies are closed. Some details, such as access rules and gate codes, may be out of date.

Nat - 12 Feb 2015

What are the ethics around perth for glueing existing holds (not in a quarry)? For example, if a flake that is crucial to a climb is very suspect is it ok to glue it so the glue cannot be seen?

I have two trains of thoughts:

-The flake should be glued to avoid falling on a belayer or causing injury to the climber.

-The glueing of the flake may be considered by some as "bringing a climb down to the climbers level" or may be considered unsightly if it is noticable.

I understand glue may not hold and may also provide a false sense of security to the leader, however the crucial hold falling off may forever destroy the climb, or worse hurt some one.

What are everyone's thoughts?


Ang - 13 Feb 2015

An interesting question.
Are you referring to a particular climb or is this just hypothetical?
There are such flakes/holds at Churchmans like that...


Nat - 13 Feb 2015

Hypothetical. I have seen some holds glued in Perth in the quarries. I was just thinking about all of the suspect flakes I have come by over the last few years and looked at other forums on the same topic with mixed responses. Be interested to know the ethics in Perth (not including quarries).

I have read some discussion on this site from about 9 years ago, but they don't really have an outcome on the ethics.


Ang - 16 Feb 2015

There don't seem to be any clear answers for this question.
You did not specify if you are referring to just bolted climbs but I'll assume you are. A big fat no to glue on trad routes. I'm not going anywhere near mixed routes!

This is just my opinion. I'm curious to see what others think.
For a bolted non-quarry line : Well, the climb has already being "manufactured" to some extent by bolting to make it protectable. I have seen bolted lines with crucial holds glued (at the time of bolting) for exactly the situations you are describing , and it seems to be acceptable to a degree. This is the grey area- how far does the gluing go? Is there such a thing as retro-gluing? Bolts have made the climb safer so why not glue holds as well, for the same reason? Bolts aren't exactly pretty to start with so unsightly glue isn't ideal, but sometimes necessary. Bolts can give a false sense of security to a leader too (there is the assumption a bolt is always bomber).


Bob - 16 Feb 2015

No need to over think it.
If it is essential to the climb then glue it. Trad or bolted.

Predominantly, the glue is used to keep the climb climbable; not for safety wrt attaching loose things.


mikl law - 2 Apr 2015

If you do it well (minimal amount of glue, clean excess off, colour the glue with sand and dust) no-one will notice.

Keep climbing with us

Keep climbing with us

Keep climbing with us