/

/

2 new routes at Willys

First Ascents

2 new routes at Willys

Started by Ross

·

·

49 replies

Archived thread

Replies are closed. Some details, such as access rules and gate codes, may be out of date.

Ross - 7 Oct 2004

New climbs - Willyabrup

Hole World (18m, 16)

Start 1.5m L of Orryjohn, at R end of overhang. Pull up on jugs, then up and L to large broken hole. Directly up buttress above, past a second, smaller hole. Trad, good gear/solid rock, take a no. 2 or 3 cam for the top hole. FA: Ross Weiter, Dinah Pantic, 3/10/04.

** <name unknown> (35m, 20)

This follows the line of “Simply Suicide” up to its first carrot, then goes up the face just L of SS. I climbed this on-sight last weekend and it seems that the crux is still getting past the old SS carrot. There are 5 new bolts with fixed hangers and one old, partially pulled-out carrot (which protects the crux). Take 2 medium cams, one for the mid-height break, and one for the near-top break. There were some comments on the CAWA web (discussion under “bolting”/”grid bolting at Gracetown crag”) that this is not a retro-bolt - half of it is. However it turned a crap climb into a good one, except for that old carrot. FA: Pascal Camison (?) Feb 2003.


Toc - 8 Oct 2004

Hi Ross,

Firstly, Dreamweaver (Mt Frankland) had many ascents on the weekend. Everybody who could lead it did, and everybody else seconded. Some did both. For three people it was their first ever multi pitch climb.

Thanks from all of us. It's a good line and the protection is considerate.

One climber tested out the 5th bolt on the second pitch when she stood on a piece of rock which broke under her feet. You'll be glad to know the bolt passed with flying colours.

Secondly, the line you have called "Hole World" I'm pretty sure is something I lead sometime in 1996 with Adrian Wood seconding. (Very kind of him, considering his ability.) At the time I was wandering along the cliff with no guide, looked up and decided it would go, not knowing whether it had been lead or not. I didn't bother to write it up as I felt sure, so obvious a line would already be done. Even when I realized it wasn't in the old guide, I didn't really expect I had the first ascent and it wasn't until a trip I made early this year with Ursula, when I got the new Margaret River guide and checked it out I was reasonably certain I had actually done the first ascent.

I'll have another look next time I'm down there, but I'm just about 100% certain your climb and my climb are exactly the same one. If so, it needs a few more ascents to confirm the grade as both Adrian and I graded it at 15.

Cheers,

Toc.

By the way, I had been planning a trip with Liz to reclimb it, and then I was going to write it up and call it Que? because of the shape of the feature low down, Dinah said looked a bit like an S and I have thought of as a ? or an ear and because of all the time I spent questioning whether or not I had a first ascent, but you seem to have beat me to writing it up, but not the FA.


Ross - 8 Oct 2004

Maybe you did second it 8 years ago, maybe the Oldies did it in the 70's, or maybe a bobtrail slithered up it 1000 years ago. Who knows for sure ?

I think it is fair to apply the commonly accepted rule applied to all areas of authorship -"Publish or Perish".


Toc - 12 Oct 2004

Ross,

If it were decided by the commonly accepted rules of authorship the acronym would be FP not FA.

First ascent means first ascent not second ascent but I published first.

I did discuss the common rules of etiquette that apply in this case with people we both respect and after doing so I decided I was correct to claim the first ascent, for the simple reason that I did do the first ascent.

Cheers,

Toc.

PS Why don't we call it "The Que? Hole"

It's a better name than either we thought of.

PPS I note that you have credited Pascal with his line, though you have published it first.


Ross - 12 Oct 2004

Actually, I just remembered I climbed in 1994. Sorry about memory lapse, but I guess the first ascent is mine after all.


Ross - 12 Oct 2004

....did that wind you up ?

OK, go down there and if you are sure that the line I describe is the one you did in 96 then it's your FA. "The Que? Hole" sounds clever and fine.

What do other people think about this kind of thing ? I've done several other "First Ascent" climbs and people came to me and said "I have done this 3 years before you and did not bother to publish it as I was too slack/modest/did not think it was worth it, but now I remembered/changed my mind/think it is important and want my name on the FA" ?

In the Perth guidebook I always gave it to them. An FA is an FA but it seems unfair on people like me and Dinah who get all excited and hoon up a 16 that we would otherwise just walk on by. Obviously Toc is a credible source but what if someone just made this up ? Any thoughts (from others than Toc) ?

(This web site has not had a decent discussion for a while so how about it ?)


Glenn - 13 Oct 2004

Ross:

During my time in QLD this would often happen...

a story:

Once, after slogging our way uphill in QLD summer heat (for 4 hours) we climbed a so-called "new" route, only to later discover that Fred Frome had soloed it many years before. We credited Fred with the FA (even though, or perhaps because, he was deceased; and even more significantly was a good bloke).

my philosophy:

I dont really care who climbs a route first; its not important to me who's name is in a guidebook. Infact, like many climbers, I often go to a cliff without a guide book to capture the spirit of the FA. Anyone can do this if they wish (provided the cliff is not damaged to the point that every hold is chalked, polished and obvious - a much more important issue than the FA in my view)

However for the purposes of compiling a factual record (guidebook), if the source is credible, then surely an FA is a FA, with or without publication.

Hence, in my view the FA is now Toc's (like yourself I beleive he is credible) until someone with an earlier claim presently contradictory evidence.


Dinah - 13 Oct 2004

In my humble opinion as a fair and reasonably logical person;

1: If it is important to have your name as the first ascentionist (as Toc does in this case) then the responsibility lies with that person to make it known about the first ascent around the time it occurred. If you do not verbally tell people or formally publish a new route then no one will know the route exists and you are asking for someone else to come along and climb it thinking THEY made the first ascent.

2: When there is dispute it is important to make sure you are both talking about exactly the same line. In the case in question I gather you are both happy that it is the same route?

3: The Pascal new route is pretty much common knowledge as there was alot of discussion about it recently on the CAWA website and around the traps.

4: Most climbers only climb existing routes and many only climb limited grades. To not publish is to possibly add confusion at a later stage and limit the crag to less adventurous climbers.

So it is not just about names and peoples egos. There are other considerations and responsibilities.

When a route is published it should have a route description which is important as it is the start or basis of the decision making process when a climber assesses a climb (particularly the less experienced climbers). A good route description will let a climber know if they are going to attempt something possibly outside of their abilities

There are people who just climb, put up routes and don't mention anything to anyone else. They probably don't care if someone else comes along and does the same routes and puts their name on it. They just want to climb. But if you are not that sort of person then make sure you do the right thing at the time to protect acknowledgment of your climbing achievements and to share the climb with others.


Toc - 13 Oct 2004

Ross,

Firstly, if the climb was too low graded to be worth your while if it had already been done, why do it at all? Secondly, a grade 15/16 is an excellent lead for Dinah, but it wasn't her who lead it and if it had been a first ascent other than something I had unfortunately already done, she could have had her first real first ascent rather than tagging along behind you.

When I first lead it I, could see from the ground it was doable for me and at the time I was falling off a sizeable percentage of the 18s I attempted, so even if it was too low a grade for someone of your high level of ability, it was perfect for somebody like Dinah or me. By the way, Adrian Wood isn't a bad climber either and he seemed quite happy to second me on something around 10 grades below where he was at. Could be just a different mindset. And another by the way; I wasn't wound up as I knew for certain if you had done it in 1994 you would have published immediately.

What I was doing at the time was exactly as Glenn suggested, climbing without a guide book. He's right it's good fun.

Dinah,

I have explained in an earlier posting why I hadn't yet published the route. Don't forget also there wasn't the ease of the website to publish at the time. I have published other routes I have put up as well as introducing people to a new crag that Andrew Garvin and I guessed existed at Mt Singleton and then took the trouble to go and look for. One of those people introduced was Ross. Unfortunately that is now closed as the landholders have been frightened by their insurance brokers. But ok, I will publish details of a few routes Andrew and I put up in the Pilbara, and a couple of others Doctor Dave and I and some others did in the Kimberleys, just as soon as I find the route descriptions.

Cheers to you both,

Toc.


Ross - 14 Oct 2004

Toc...what makes you think "the climb was too low graded to be worth my while ?" I have walked past 50 other climbs on that day, many of them definitely "hard enough" to be "worth my while". We also did "Faith", an excellent 14, done a million times before. Where does that leave your argument - firmly on the nose, I think.

And what makes you think that Dinah "tagged along" - you think she is so weak minded that she cannot assert herself if she does not want to do a route ? And you also seem to think that she never had a "real ascent", or that seconding is not a "real ascent". In that case Jon and I never really ascended "The Nose" in Yosemite as we both seconded (in fact jumared) half of it. Who do you think you are ? This web site was not created for you to slander off people you have a problem with, so kindly think before writing and stick to facts.


John Knight - 15 Oct 2004

Easy fellers, geez, you're acting like chuffing kids.


Matt - 15 Oct 2004

FA’s don’t need to be registered for the greater good. Sometimes a climber doesn’t think it’s worthwhile such as if it’s a 16 that we would otherwise just walk on by..

However, if you don’t publish a route then:

1. expect that with the number of climbers out there, the limited number of climbing locations, and the facility of newsgroups, some-one will publish your climb.

2. have the humility to accept the authors diligence.

In the context of a FA, it’s generally accepted that climbing as a “second” is not a real ascent.

I’ll be at Willys on the weekend and will check out this infamous line. It better be worth all this typing..


Toc - 16 Oct 2004

My God, has this ever got out of hand.

I quote, "An FA is an FA but it seems unfair on people like me and Dinah who get all excited and hoon up a 16 that we would otherwise just walk on by".

If that's not saying you wouldn't have bothered with it if it weren't a first ascent then I read it wrong.

After that. I'm used to climbing with climbers of all abilities and sharing/swapping leads whatever our respective abilities. When I have climbed with Dinah, we shared leads and there is certainly no way I could or would ever dream of saying or intimating she were weak minded. Slander doesn't come into it.

Matt,

I liked the route and at the time I didn't know it was a first ascent. I just liked it. I don't think it's a great route, but it's a good route, it's direct and it's fun. I think we'd all like to know your opinion on the grade.

It wasn't humility that stopped me from publishing early or particularly ego that had me claiming it now, it's just an historically accurate statement. But yes, there is a certain charge in getting an FA and I do have enough competitiveness in me to like that charge, as does Ross, and Dinah, who has got a kick out of seconding them, when she does find and lead an FA will get an even bigger charge. Isn't it a buzz that they are still out there in Western Australia to be had?

Particularly a fully natural line like this one which takes no more than the climbing to do.

Nextly, it was not until years later I realized it was an FA, something I have already said and yes I did since discuss it with other people, even pointing it out to them. But I wanted to reclimb it so my route description would be fresh and not from my weak and failing memory and hence possibly dangerous. I should also point out that the people I have spoken to, Ross, Dinah and I are far from strangers to each other. To pretend to Dinah and Ross that I didn't know of any other FA would be an insult, and if they ever found out, which is highly likely, they'd want to know why I hadn't spoken.

Now "Dreamweaver" which Ross put up at Mt Frankland is another proposition altogether. It took a lot of effort and commitment, an amount of vision and is gift to all the rest of us and I certainly for one, appreciate, thank and commend his efforts there as, does everybody else who climbed it on the last association trip.

"The Que? Hole", was a half hour climb including getting the second up, whereas "Dreamweaver", was a two day effort, plus the cost of materials, and then climbing it without ever knowing for sure until his first ascent, whether all his effort was going to be worth it. There's a hell of a difference. "The Que? Hole" is fun and was no effort to put up, "Dreamweaver" is a lot of fun and was a huge effort to put up. Enjoy them both. I did.

Regards to all,

Toc.


Steve Digwood - 3 Nov 2004

Guys - A lot of messages over one climb.

Since Ross was the first person to go to the time & trouble to name and write up this climb, to me that gives him naming rights on it.

Any of the possible earlier ascentionists could have done the same, but chose not to.

Given the number of people who climb at Wilyabrup and the time that it has been a climbing area, it is quite likely that it has been climbed in the past.

Maybe the best thing is to put Ross's & Dinah's names of the climb, but also add a comment like "first ascent unknown" or "first ascent uncertain" to reflect that it has probably been climbed by others in the past.


Eugene Snorkelbender - 13 Nov 2004

Too much politics fellas. Either both of you need to get lives or simply tone down the ego (most likely all of the above). It's all very pathetic- but entertaining none-the-less. Keep up the good work.


Toc - 13 Nov 2004

Hi Eugene,

Toc and Ross are our real names. Everyone knows who we are and what we stand or don't stand for, and we both have very real and active lives.

Cheers.


Eugene Snorkelbnder - 16 Nov 2004

Why not call the climb 'Who gives a s@#t, it's just a piece of rock'. Then when somebody asks you what you climbed at Willy's you can answer by saying "Who gives a s@#t, it's just a piece of rock".


Eddie Baby - 16 Nov 2004

No, Eugene, this is serious.

While you or I, if someone came up and said, “I did that years ago”, we’d say “no worries”, and write it up with their name, or somebody’s name, or whatever. But there are some people who take this seriously.

TOC has recognised this and is deliberately trying to make Ross’ head explode. True the entertainment value is high but it is very cruel. He should desist and apologise.

(Personally I attribute my first ascents to John Howard. Never had a complaint.)


Eugene Snorkelbender - 17 Nov 2004

You make a good point Eddie Baby. However, whilst Toc does enjoy a good wind up we cannot ignore the stubbornness of both parties. Why can't they just be friends and meet halfway. Both have made considerable contributions to climbing in W.A. over the years, both out at the crags and in the commitee room, but nobody- repeat, nobody- owns the rock we climb, even if they were the first... or second... or second last... or thier mothers first born... or thier mother's 8th born... or if they were raised by a pack of Hungarian wolves in my home town of Kilimanjaro after being abandoned at birth. The rock was there millions of years before us and will be there millions of years after we're gone. We have until sunset to work it out... Some people need a drama in thier lives.

As my father once said, "Son (always begins with 'son'), you're going to be dead one day, and your whole life will have meant nothing!"


John Knight - 17 Nov 2004

I've gotta say, I agree with snorkel wobbler here.


Diane - 17 Nov 2004

Geez guys, for those of you who don't think an FA is a big deal . . . .

There is a hell of a difference between leading up a route you've never been on before, and *knowing* that route is of a rating that you're capable of (cos someone else rated it for you)- versus leading off on something NO-ONE has been on and that you only *think* you're capable of!

Although established routes are far from surprise-free, you generally will know something about them. If you're the first person on a route (or even if you only think you are!), the risks are that much greater.

Therefore my respect for anyone who does something as a first ascensionist, whether they really are the first or not, is right up there. I don't think I'll ever have the guts to walk up to a chunk of rock that I know absolutely nothing about and cast off on the sharp end.

And for those who publish their FAs so that the rest of us can go and have a play given some knowledge of how difficult the route may be, THANK YOU! You not only put yourself at risk physically more than the rest of us, but you also risk being dragged over the coals by anyone who then doesn't like your route!

And for goodness sake Eugene and whoever else is using pseudonyms, grow some balls and use your real names!


Eddie Baby - 17 Nov 2004

My, there are so many angry people in the world.

Eugene your dad put his finger on it. Meaning is temporary. In the long run we’re all dead. The anarchy inherent in climbing makes this attribution of first ascents somewhat notional.

As you say the rock is for ever and ever. Except of course for the quarries. And some of those chipped routes. And no one owns the rock. Dubious claims by CALM, traditional owners and various property developers apart. So as Jack Nicholson said in the art movie Mars Attacks, just before the martians shot him, “Why can’t we just get along?”

People write up climbs so they can talk about them, get other opinions and relive the experience. And then those who come after can try alternatives, straiten the line, and all that. It’s all about drinks in the clubhouse and dreams and schemes. To make this a competitive event by demanding a particular recognition from an indifferent world is a curious variation. Not wishing to follow the modern pattern of attaching a value judgement to every observation, I might say - well, in some circles that’s how the game is played.

Then again as my old nan used to say, “pley naisly, don’t’a fait.”

It’s convenient that people do first ascents and write them up. But there is no need to be grateful. They’re doing it because they enjoy it, and if they didn’t. Well we’d have to do it ourselves, and it would be fun. I’ve done some first ascents (preen preen), admittedly not usually on purpose. Generally on longer natural (easy) routes where you’re halfway up with five pitches to go and you’ve been lost since pitch three. I haven’t written much up, and as Claire says, perhaps I am not properly considerate of the adoring multitude. Who would bestrew my path with roses as is the due of every first ascentionist.

Tread carefully, remember, the biggest egos are the most fragile.


Eugene Snorkelbender - 18 Nov 2004

Knighty & Eddie Baby, thanks for your support. Good to see there are other rational & unselfish thinkers out there. Rock climbing is, like all other sports, a game which should be enjoyed with friends, not full of conflict between apparent competitiors off the field. One of the reasons I enjoy it so much is because it is us against the rock, not us against each other. Unfortunately when this kind of arguement arises it brings the sport into total disrepute. Seriously Toc & Ross, are you here to support rock climbing as a whole, or is your sole objective to support yourselves in a vien effort to boost your own ego's? Think about that.

As for Diane... well how would you like it if your parents thought it would be amusing to change your name by deed poll to something like Eugene Snorkelbender when you were 7 years old. After all those years of being picked on in the school ground over my name I finally thought I'd found sanctuary when I discovered the understanding and accepting nature of rock climbers, only to now find someone thinks my name is so ridiculous that it must be a pseudonym. As my fiancee Ophelia Balls always says, "Ugliness and bad names are only skin deep". Although just between you and me I think she secretly is looking forward to being Ophelia Snorkelbender.


Toc - 18 Nov 2004

Hi to all,

Thanks Diane.

Eugene if you don't like your name, change it. Just make sure that everybody knows who you are all of the time. Course you could be joking, who knows.

As for supporting rockclimbing, I'm not going to be secretary next year. Neither will Ross, he's done it before too. Want a job?

Whatever else Ross and I may or not not be, we will stand up and if people really want to throw rocks at us, at least they'll be certain of who their targets are. And are we ever competitive, you bet we are.

By the way, "The Que Hole" is an amalgamation of both the names we had given it. Initially I wasn't too impressed with it as a name, but I really like it now. I hope Ross does as well. So how about somebody else go and climb it, because we're still disputing the grade.

Cheers all,

Toc.


Crosby Darwinian - 18 Nov 2004

Phoowhey! Poor Ross and Toc, I'm sure they didn't mean for it to end up like this. But I sure am enjoying it!

... and i like the pseudos, it adds a bit of mystery and allows people to inject some wisdom and humour without adding their own ego into the mix.

I do like a debate - sometimes the fingers type faster than the brain can judge though. Trigger happy?

Something my mother never said to me: "Opinions are like arseholes. Everyone's got one and some of them stink". (Not that yours does of course.)


Jamie - 18 Nov 2004

nothing like a good strong discussion...but to all those who are currently chipping in about this "disagreement" go back and re-read the thread....ross credited toc with the first assent and the proposed merging of the name back in reply 5....and everyone is carrying it on

having said that...

the rock has been there for however many million years and will be there for however more million years long after all the names we give routes have been forgotton..so in the whole picture names and grades have very little meaning..

but for us in the here and now...a first assent is not there for everyone to look at the assentants name and bow down and worship them...but rather just give then the respect and credit they deserve for getting out there and furthering the sport...taking nothing from eugene and eddie who may very well like many others just like getting out there and climbing a chunk of rock regardless of names and grades just for the pleasure of climbing....

but for most of us climbing is a sport as well as a lifestyle where we compete against ourselves...and the measure or the competition is in the grades....big thank you to those out there that get out there and put up the new stuff and an even bigger thanks to those that spend the time, effort and expense of putting in fixed protection...

cheers all

jamie


Eugene Snorkelbender - 18 Nov 2004

Name changing isn't such a bad idea Toc. Any suggestions?


John Knight - 18 Nov 2004

Thankfully I've got one of the coolest names on the planet, hehe. Any harsh words to Diane will result from a karate chop from me, so don't get too heated yourself Diane. ;)

Nothing to cause more debate here, but when I make new routes (although boulder routes don't seem to be considered real or respectable in WA), I mainly want people to drop in and make more routes in the same region.

Now some fellow Stoneville climbers have come in and setup a new route in my 'sanctuary', I couldn't be more stoked (G'day cam and squirmy by the way!). :D

It's only fair to credit climbers who've set routes there previously, as I would like in the same situation, but if anyone wants to really claim ownership of the place, hmmmmmmm........


Eddie Baby - 18 Nov 2004

Eugene, do not be discouraged. When the discussion turns from the issues at hand to your name, or the funny shape of your nose, or the brief acquaintance of your parents, then you know you have struck a chord. The secret is to speak to the wider audience.

Although it may not have been wise to give your full name. TOC says he wants everyone to know where he lives so they can come around and throw rocks at him. It is conceivable that those of a more sensitive and retiring nature, not wanting to have their lights punched out by the FA fan club, might be more circumspect in their communication.

And to Jamie, if you think all is sweetness and light, try reply 9 for a colourful dummy spit. Still if they both want to call themselves the first ascensionist, well why not. We’ll put their names up with Buhl, Messner, Rathbone and the two Ronnies. But is it not these star-crossed lovers that now concern us. The gulf that divides them is wide and probably goes beyond 8m of grade 16.

No. It is the exploration of the theory of cosmic insignificance. And why the canonisation of the first ascensionist can only be a futile gesture against the dust of the centuries. Some climbers open routes, some put in bolts. And if we hear about a good line with a few bolts we try it and compare notes. And maybe we find a line and put in a bolt, or take one out. And if you think putting in bolts is hard, taking unnecessary bolts out cleanly can be very tricky. The whole thing works pretty well and we usually manage not to do irreparable damage. And if people want to yell at each other, well, as my old nana Fatima Habibi, God grant her peace, used to say, “Edwaard, you stan behin’ de camel, he shit on you.”


Jamie - 18 Nov 2004

i said nothing about this being all sweetness and light...only that the issue of the first ascent was delt with by reply 5.....and it seems that there is a great deal of reading between the lines, misunderstandings and hurt feelings...

think everything should be just put behind us and get on with whats really at issue...having a good climb and enjoying ourselves


Eugene Snorkelbender - 19 Nov 2004

Now that young Jamie, was a dummy spit. Consider yourself intentionally wound up and covered in camel shit.


Jamie - 19 Nov 2004

yawns...

sorry what was that eugene?


John Knight - 19 Nov 2004

Gordon Bennett! Anyone in favour of deleting this thread?


Edward - 22 Nov 2004

And so dear reader, all the contenders have fled the field.

It’s so quiet in here.

But you ask, did it mean anything at all

Life's but a walking shadow; a poor player,

That struts and frets his hour upon the stage,

And then is heard no more: it is a tale

Told by an idiot, full of sound and fury,

Signifying nothing.

Good night children. Everywhere.


Dinah - 22 Nov 2004

Hush.....I'm sleeping.


Toc - 23 Nov 2004

Hi all,

I'll say this quietly so as not to awaken Dinah, I have not left the field.

I would appreciate someone else climb The Que Hole so we can get some more opinions on the grade and when you do let us know.

Cheers all,

Toc.

By the way, I can't be on committee next year, neither can some of the others, so if anyone out there wants to really support climbing in WA, how about doing what Ross and I have both done and put your hands up.


Bert - 23 Nov 2004

I've been following the discussion with a certain dramatic anticipation to the outcome, but, I am still no wiser, can someone tell me who it was, that ended up with the bigger willie.


Ross - 29 Nov 2004

G'day wordsmiths,

I have left WA and am now working and living in Oman (this email is sent from my office in Muscat) for a few years. Thanks for all your contributions, amongst us we have set a CAWA record, which is great.

Just to explain, I did not set this up as a public argument because I wanted Toc and myself to give ourselves black eyes. I have had enough private emails with Toc and have shared a house with him for a year and we can certainly talk (most of the time). This discussion was set up because (a) the CAWA web site had gone a bit quiet over winter and (b) I really wanted to know what other people think about this. If I can just briefly respond to a few things:

I think all discussion is worthwhile, about anything. In my experience people who say "this is not worth discussing" only do so to boost their own egos; e.g. to say "I'm so clever this is below me". Bollocks, if you have nothing to contribute - then say nothing. We must discuss things.

Communication is what has driven the human race forward. In the long run we will all be dead, our guidebooks dust and deeds forgoten, but if one takes this attitude literally then why live at all ? Why not just jump off the top of Bluff Knoll, eh ?

Discussion leads to for politics (and sometimes is mistaken for politics) and in Australia politics is a dirty word. But politics is how things happen ! Without discussing, understanding each other, getting other people's opinions and working with them, any one person will achieve little. One climber's voice counts for little in the wider world - hence we have CAWA (notice how we have no climbing bans in this state ?)

So, to wrap this up, I respect Toc - he pisses me off often and I know I piss him off too. But we can live with that, and we use our real names and we have real lives....way beyond what you would believe from these emails. We both care about climbing it is important to us and we talk about it. Even though one day we will be fogotten.

By the way, what is wrong with having an ego ? I think a stong ego is critical in a sport like this, i.e. strong belief in one's self. It has got me through some very sticky situations where doubting one's ability is not a good idea. Egos are hard to kill, unlike shirking violets.

Anyway, that's it. Rumour has it that there is a fair bit of chossy limestone here, some of it over 2000m high. Me, my ego, hopefully some other lunatic and my trad climbing gear look forward to the battles to come.

Until we turn to dust - good luck to you all, go climb a rock. Again, thanks for comments.

Ross


John Knight - 29 Nov 2004

Gee Ross, that's a bit of a shock! Well... have fun in Oman. :) I know our opinions have differed sometimes, but massive respect for all you've done. I'm hoping to follow in your footsteps for the bouldering world and produce a few guides, etc. Although anything nearly as huge and comprehensive as your effort would be something difficult!

Cheers mate! :)

John


Toc - 30 Nov 2004

Come back Ross, all is forgiven.

Just joking, enjoy Oman. I would.

I could not have expressed those sentiments better and completely agree.

Cheers,

Toc.


Eddy Baby - 2 Dec 2004

Dang !

Just when you think you've had the last word everyone else chips in.

.

So what was it all about. Well the original matter was concisively dealt with in the Glen/Matt replies, about 6/11. Thereafter one protagonist lapsed into silence the other into incoherence.So we got to talk about meaning and the importance of being in on a FA and guidebook glory. Really it was just an opportunity to hang out and chat with the other groupies.

All Quite fun. Not beneath us at all. If it were beneath us we wouldn't carry on like this. No, we wouldn't say anything. Those who find this beneath them remain silent. Which is probably why we're such a select little group. If I may include myself in the small but happy band that has colonised this web site.

And now the first protagonist has made a political comeback. How to comment?

So what is wrong with egotism?

This is what is wrong with egotism.

"Who do you think you are? This web site was not created for you to slander off people.......you think she is so weak minded that she cannot assert herself...... go and jump off Bluff Knol... rant rant"

Ok, but does it matter? What consenting adults do in the privacy of an internet website is up to them (I'm sure if Brittney Spears set up a webcam in her shower none of us would intrude).

After all it's not like noisy neighbours keeping me awake all night. So egotism, while distasteful, should be harmless, and useful sometimes in identifying difficult children. Not to mention its role in politics.


Glenn - 3 Dec 2004

I like your critical thinking. When I was younger I had no appreciation for the influence that our collective social behaviour plays in influencing our actions and ideas.

Jackie Kiewa wrote a very interesting PhD thesis on this topic, which was published around 2001 (Griffith Uni, Qld, Australia). I believe she discovered that climbers, like many other social groups, construct their own socially acceptable behaviours, and even “myths” and/or hero’s (not to mention villians...). Apparently, sometimes we form very fixed ideas on what is “good” and what is “bad”, what is right and wrong. It seems we make our own ideology, and sometimes we even enforce it on others, even when we don’t know we are doing it.

(In truth, I still have very little knowledge in this area, but its fun to think).

Perhaps this topic on free ascents is a “case in point”. The concepts are subjective, the social behaviour, fragmented in its views, but guided by entrenched ideology. The result: chaos. I love it.


Ophelia Balls - 6 Dec 2004

Well, might I say that the social construct of the spinning infinity of the hurdy gurdy which creates a phsycological vacuum after the worlds stage that children see as a paranormal adduct becomes reality two fold the intensity of the previous one stands up and says "What a load of s#*t, this has nothing to do with rock climbing at all".

But, as my father Humungous once said, "If god didn't want us to manipulate the genome of the Golden Canola plant, he wouldn't have given us restriction enzymes".


Princess of Light - 6 Dec 2004

Huh?


Glenn - 7 Dec 2004

I don’t reply to people not willing to use their own name, or those without manors.

G


Ophelia Balls - 7 Dec 2004

That is a reply Glen.


Edward - 7 Dec 2004

Yes Glen, absolute chaos.

And if you think this lot is odd, try the VCC, or BMC for that matter. Or of course the rapacious DOC.


Toc - 18 Dec 2004

Hi all,

I did my second ascent of "The Que Hole" two weekends ago during the CAWA trip. Aiden Beyer seconded. It was Aiden's first trip away and he seemed pretty happy about it. I must have been having a very good day back 8 years ago, as I agree it is a 16 not a 15.

One of the reasons I didn't publish early this year when I realized it had been a first ascent, is I had thought the that by the time you have climbed the buttress you're a bit run out and if you are not climbing several grades higher than this as Ross or even I, are, you might want a bolt.

What do you think Ross? There is good gear below the buttress and a bomber #3 Hex placement (side on) above it, but I didn't find anything in the middle, either time I've done it.

Cheers,

Toc.


Ross - 18 Dec 2004

Hi Toc. I found a mid-size cam placement in the middle of the buttress, 4m above the que-hole (in another, much smaller hole). I did not place any gear to the side. I trust you are well and hope that this helps.

Ross


G - 1 Sep 2005

why are you guys such nerds talking with such a confusing vocaulary ??

Keep climbing with us

Keep climbing with us

Keep climbing with us