First Ascents
12 months on and a new route at Mountain Quarry
Started by Jim Truscott
·
·
63 replies
Archived thread
Replies are closed. Some details, such as access rules and gate codes, may be out of date.
Jim Truscott - 30 Dec 2007
Get out of bed early to prevent having to queue on the back wall for this one. A diet lacking in red meat and alcohol can lead to uncertainty and pretence in the face of carrots
Carroterrorism 30m 23.425
The playstation just to the left of LOTD with five acts and no half-way house. Act 1; eat plenty of baby carrots and scheme to get your wife on the warpath. Act 2; climb the bulging wall with lubra lips precision and positive, high thoughts. Act 3; surmount the awkward block and low traverse up the ramp. Act 4; ascend the overhanging wall with much determination and nervous energy. Retain the energy necessary to rip off a sprayed on condom for the move up to the last clip. Act 5; take the train to Mandurah, hoot, hoot. 10BR to DBB. M Rosser, D. Zonta 30 Dec 07
Blair - 30 Dec 2007
Good work on putting up a new climb guys. Maybe a change of vegetables are in order, from carrots to pees maybe?
Matt Rosser - 31 Dec 2007
Download the 15MB video clip here
www.savefile.com/projects/1060568
or see a low res version here:
www.youtube.com/watch?v=XxBha59cD1M
awe inspired rad guy - 1 Jan 2008
wow!! thats amazing, what a climb! and now when i go to you tube and watch world class climbers on world class routes i can also watch some grainy footage of a budget class chipped route equipped with carrot bolts!! brilliant!! how did you manage to find so much money to buy the computers, modems, handy cams, drills, harness, ropes, cars and still not find enough to place decent bolts!! brilliant
well done
i'm amazed
that anyone still does this....
Elliot - 1 Jan 2008
I love how you didn't use your name with that post.
You're all class.
Jeff M - 2 Jan 2008
I will use my name, I agree with the other guys, time to retire the whole carrot bolt mindset. If you are creating a sport route use some kind of ring or P, if the area is sensitive use GIMB's or paint whatever sort of ring you use to blend in. If it is a Mixed route, then I can certainly see a place for a heap of GIMB's. I mean if you are going to have to lock in one spot to place gear you can do the same to place a hanger right?
But here is the overall point, CARROTS ARE CRAP! You guys seem willing to spend heaps of cash on some things then skimp on others. If you do not have the funds to put decent bolts in all of the many routes you guys put up, then how about putting up less climbs and make them of better quality?
ed nepia - 3 Jan 2008
good one putting up another new route, but heres a question for you.. if a route has to be chipped for you to climb it can I re-chip it to make sure I can climb it?
seems fair...
a wombat (one of many) - 3 Jan 2008
... try that on punks in the gym at araps and see what happens....or hang ten or urban ethics or chips and dips or sweetpea etc etc or any of the perth "classics"
ed nepia - 3 Jan 2008
oh i get it .. its ok to chip a route to suit the first ascentionest only... righto that makes perfect sense
its a wierd world alright
so how about filling in holds that have been chipped then doing the route?
Neil - 3 Jan 2008
hasn't this been covered like a squillion times before on this website?
hi to all the wombats out there :-P
ed nepia - 3 Jan 2008
yes i can see how outrageously busy this site is ..... errrrr ummmmm
the judge - 3 Jan 2008
chipping routes is bullshit, why not just drill a hole and put a climbing hold on the rock or glue one on its the the same bullshit. if you are chipping routes to make a new one then people should be able to fill them in or chip them more to make it climable for them. personally i think if you are chipping routes you are a useless wanker.
Kris - 4 Jan 2008
Chip, glue, carrot, do whatever the hell you like in the quarries. They are fake environments and i personally couldn't give a rats what goes on in there. Soon the CAWA / DEC nazis will probably ban us from going in there anyway.
However, no way in hell should chipping, glueing etc occur on natural crags. Anyone seen the appauling chip job done at Gracetown? You are a tosser whoever it was.
Matt, Jim, do i detect some baiting going on with your last few climbs??
All named after those poxey carrots you insist on using. Good onya for putting up the climb, pity you ruin your good work with outdated, dangerous equipment.
Happy 08 everyone
ed nepia - 4 Jan 2008
'carroterrorism', 'year of the carrot', 'triumph of the carrot', 'carrots for rabbits'
haha
yep real funny cutting edge names
so actually the use of carrots is an anarchistic, subversive counterculture.. how daring, how noble... that'll really show those wimpy, losers with their bombproof glue-in bolts
and when some unfortunate , unsuspecting climber decks after one of the carrots pulls we'll all get the joke
haha
Marianne - 4 Jan 2008
I've had the good fortune to climb recently in Spain (sports), the UK (trad) and Thailand (sports). Because I started climbing (properly) in Perth I didn't really think anything of carrots..a climb was a climb. I've got to admit though that watching my technique improve out of sight on sports climbs, and testing my nerves on trad climbs are the most satisfying types of climbing for me :-)
p.s. It'd be interesting to see what happened if anyone tried to put up a carrot climb in Thailand!
vegan - 4 Jan 2008
i like carrots, especially juiced or cut thinly in stir fry with lashings of ginger and soy
i am therefore surprised to see that anyone would use these noble vegetables for protecting a rock climb
surely the climbing world has moved on from the bash in bolt era?
liberate the carrot! return the carrot to its rightful place on the table of the nation and off the cliff!!
THE JUDGE - 4 Jan 2008
i wonder if these idiots who are actualy putting in carrots can be held responsible for their actions should some unfortunate person die from climbing their chipped and carrotted climb.
Shannon - 4 Jan 2008
I doubt it coz you climb at your own risk.
Though with the whole new DEC system coming in, with people having to book to be in some quarries, you think they would insist on a certain standard of bolting to be used.
Lets face it, the cost of decent anchors is not that high so there is really no reason to continue with such an outdated practice as bashing in carrots eh?
Neil - 5 Jan 2008
...so donate some money or bolts to the rebolting fund / safer cliffs wa.
FYI bolting is expensive.
glue in p-bolts cost $4.95 and then you have to buy glue (approx $2 per bolt), drill bits ($0.50 per bolt), glue nozzles and hole brushes ($10each).
so for one glue in p-bolt the cost is easily $8 per bolt.
for an expansion bolt it is around $4 for the hanger and $3.50 for the bolt.
so including drill bits etc the cost is easily $8 a bolt once again.
if you don't believe me look at:
www.climbinganchors.com.au
and this assumes you can get the following free: a drill, static rope, an old harness - because your new slinky one will be shagged from glueing, a grigri, jumar etc etc.
FYI.... the cost of a carrot is less than $1.
i am happy to rebolt anyone's favorite carrot route. no questions asked. you just have to cough up the $$.
for people's info, there are plans to do some rebolting at bob's hollow on australia day. so if you're keen to help or see whats going on come along and sticky beak.
Shannon - 5 Jan 2008
Um I do donate to the rebolting fund, I also know how much it costs to bolt. I donate money in the jars so unsafe or worn bolts can be replaced, Why should the money I donate go to rebolting climbs that should be done properly in the first place?
Also when you tell me how much it costs to drill one type of bolt versus the other, you can leave out the drill, drill bit, harness, rope and all the other stuff that people placing carrots already have. Yes decent bolts cost a bit more but it is not astronomical, And it will save you having to waste perfectly good rebolting funds. Carrots were the norm back in the dark ages but most of us have come a long way since.
ed nepia - 5 Jan 2008
i totally agree with shannon, and Neil $8/bolt is bloody reasonable given they should have a lifespan of decades (at least)
if the cost of good bolts is too much then developers should not use a cheap, unsafe alternative instead they should leave the route undeveloped till someone else is prepared to do the job right (first time)
the guys putting up these routes obviously have lots of good energy to put into developing routes and should be thanked for that, but by failing to follow best practice and place the best possible permanent anchors they could, they do themselves and the climbing community as a whole a disservice
its taking the piss especially with the choice of route names...
richard - 7 Jan 2008
If you don’t like carrots then don’t climb on them. If you really don’t like carrots then replace them with gluein hex-heads. If you really don’t like carrots and you want to whinge then replace them and whinge. If you just want to whinge then talk about Brittney Spears.
ed nepia - 7 Jan 2008
thank you for that helpful message... sorry you missed the point
'whingeing' about carrots is a reasonable response to some deliberately provocative 'public boasting' about carrots.
No one has bagged these guys for their positive energy in developing new routes, good on them
But the continued practice of using unsafe and outdated bolting technology is being challenged. Bolted routes should always have the best possible protection (cause there arent any other options) That dosnt mean having bolts every metre but it means that any bolt you do clip should be as strong as practical.
Back in the days of hand drills and limited technological knowhow carrot bolts where the accepted norm (at least in australia) but times have changed (in most places) and carrot bolts have now been abandoned for superior equipment.
Why ANYONE thinks its ok to keep using carrots is completly bewildering, and why some of you still think its ok is even wierder.
And yes i could replace them with GIMB or expansion bolts but why should I bother? If these guys placed decent gear in the first place no one would have to waste their time and money fixing up a mess, and we wouldnt be having these discussions
richard - 7 Jan 2008
Not aimed specifically at you Ed. The point is everyone's free to do almost anything. If we don't like what the pioneers do we're free to ignore the climb or change the bolts. Using a high moral tone to get someone else to do work is only occasionaly effective.
ed nepia - 7 Jan 2008
ok and what would be more effective?
Richard W - 7 Jan 2008
I remember when climbing was about adventure and the unique bond that one would gain with their climbing partners pushing the limits. (i.e A little bit of careing and less ego!)Placing protection that is widely deemed as unappropriate to our community is purely selfish. As is chipping routes to a degree that makes them possibly by those who are chipping. Where's the adventure gone in trying routes that are not of ones capacity? Also - every dog has their day and those ageing climbers out there should accept their age with grace and let the young ones try the lines that they cannot do. Well done to Logan who recently redpointed all the newly re-bolted lines at Mountain quarry - Fuzz Bucky, Barren Awakening etc. Training and trying is the key - not chipping the hell out of lines and placing crap gear.
Ross Weiter - 7 Jan 2008
Hey crowd what's with the aggro? Jim and Matt spend days excavating chossy and blank lines and making something out of nothing so we have something more to climb.....if you don't like it, don't climb it. For most of the time, I don't, the lines are unesthetic and do not appeal to my sense of adventure. But that's me, and many other outdoor climbers, but in most cases the lines would be unclimbable by almost anyone in their natural state. It is a choice between nothing and something. If you want to put up your routes in your style, do it. If you want to rebolt JM routes with GIMBs, do that. Quarries in Perth have always been chipped and glued, from Sweet Pea on and before too. As far as carrots go, in solid vertical granite they are fine. People using them anywhere else are being selfish. It depends. Life is not as simple as some of the contributors make out, of course having a discussion about anything is useful.
Keep talking and enjoy 2008. Enjoy JM's home video, whatever you think of it. Be positive. see ya - Ross
neil - 7 Jan 2008
and go trad climbing.
if you do enough of it... carrots don't seem too bad in certain circumstances.
ed nepia - 7 Jan 2008
trad climbing is all good, just back from 4 days at west cape so thanks for the advice
Blair - 8 Jan 2008
I'm not trying to be provocative, just trying to gain an understanding.
I have only been climbing for a couple of years and obviously this directly reflects in the climbing experience I have, which compared to most of you reading this is not that much in the big scheme of things.
So I direct this question to Jim, and brothers Rosser. Why use bash in carrots when bolting a new line? Is it that it is quicker, cheaper, easier, just as safe as using expansions, glue in P bolts/ machine bolts? Or does it simply add to the excitement, experience and stigma to climb on "only" bash in carrots? Or have I completely missed the point?
a wombat - 8 Jan 2008
not that i am matt or jim;
but i would say carrots have advatages in that they are very cheap and very quick to place compared to alternatives.
the more pragmagtic amongst us would acknowledge that they are not as good as the alternative when it comes to safety - but still safe - (whatever that means) and the more paranoid among us claim they are stupidly dangerous.
Ross Weiter - 8 Jan 2008
OK here is the argument in favour of carrots, for the newer people: (1) installed cost is 10x less than for alternatives (2)you can climb on it straight away and not wait for glue to cure in 24 hours (3) visually inobtrusive....but so a re glued in machine bolts...GIMBS (4) good shear strength....which is a function of the diameter of the bolt and not of the placement.
Against it are (1) very poor pullout strength (2) creeping out of hole with repeated falls...i.e. age badly: hence unsuitable for anything that overhangs or soft./shattered rock, (3) you cannot rap off them like you can off eyebolts and hsing bolt plates is inconvenient.
I use mostly GIMBs which address disadvantages 1&2, but add the one of having to wait for the glue to cure.
Matt and Jim use them because they see them as their trademark, it is their "mode operandi", it is who they are, and they are proud of them and themselves for using them. You will not convince them to use anything else, no matter what is said on this web site. As far as I can tell, they simply do not care what anyone else thinks. This is not uncommon in climbing, or in life, so I find it best just to shrug shoulders and look at the positives, as per prev. post....
ed nepia - 9 Jan 2008
more grist
i agree with you ross in so far as it is not uncommon for some to do whatever they like irrespective of the opinions of others
however it is also very common that climbers as a group generally conform to a set of ethics some of which are well known
these include not bolting routes which can be naturally protected, not chipping holds on natural crags (the quarrys seem to be an exception in WA),
and various versions of what constitutes good style when claiming an ascent
and worldwide there is a move toward abandoning outdated bolting technology including bash in carrots for stronger and safer alternatives such as glueins, expansion bolts ... this website under bolting ethics advocates using only materials and fixtures of suitable strength (carrot bolts are not)
problem with this is that it can become a safety issue for unsuspecting climbers in the future when as you note carrot bolts have poor strength in tension(pull out) and age badly. Visiting climbers who pick up a guide and launch onto routes at the quarrys have no way of knowing which routes have GIMB or just carrots until they are committed, they dont have the option of 'just rebolting with GIMB'
I truly believe that whenever you bolt a route (and publicise it) you have an obligation to use the best equipment possible. Otherwise your just demonstrating piss poor judgement and a lack of respect for the greater climbing community
and thats a shame
shane shaw - 9 Jan 2008
Ed, spoken like a true Mesiah. I agree with you 100 %
ed nepia - 9 Jan 2008
cheers but its just my opinion eh. i aint the messiah
Shannon - 9 Jan 2008
S'ok Ed, I am an athiest but what you are saying is spot on.
Ishmael - 9 Jan 2008
We finally establish that the purpose of what we do is to make the world safe for the inexperienced. Past wisdom has been to regard all bolts as suspect. Consider their age consider their condition consider their history. In quarries consider the entire wall may be unstable. The current push to make the outdoors an extension of the gym is laudable in many areas. Quarries are insufficiently stable for natural pro. Bob’s Hollow overhanging Limestone is suited only to u-bolts. The minimisation of hazard reduces the need for judgement allowing the masses to enjoy the clip-and-go lifestyle. We are called to work for this. It is presented to us by the messiahs of virtue and conformity as being part of a social obligation to a climbing community. And they are right. Resistance is futile. So MatandJim are hazardous, beware of MatandJim. Do not touch their routes lest you turn into a retrobolter. The grand old days are gone. It is time to be responsible.
Yes a, lot of us have worked hard for climbing. Many were misled and didn’t work for altruistic reasons, they worked for the freedom of individual initiative, for an unstructured environment, for the chance to figure things out for themselves. These things are hard to define and defend and near impossible to explain to anyone with a background in outdoor education or public service. Still - paradoxically - I’m sure I speak for most outdoor climbers when I say, long live climbing, and sod the climbing community.
ed nepia - 9 Jan 2008
well thats a very well crafted and noble essay, I had completly missed the true expression of non conformists striving for expression in this PC world, maybe they could add a piece to their youtube clips perhaps?
and yes your right society is dumbing down danger every day, sad bastards keep improving technology so that the less enlightened dont have to suffer
so look forward to watching you climbing in your sack cloth, ashes and roman sandals... hemp rope of course
........
Ishmael - 9 Jan 2008
Ahh, so satisfy my curiosity. Which are you? Outdoor education or public service?
ed nepia - 9 Jan 2008
well in a long and varied working life i have been many things including (blushes) an outdoor instructor/guide/industrial rope/avalanche forecaster and now i'm a house dad, i've also put up a bunch of new routes here and there and rebolted a few as well
but thats not what you wanted was it?
and you must have a lot of free time for an agent of the almighty or is this just a part time gig?
Ishmael - 9 Jan 2008
truely you are the Messiah
though you should brush up on your biblical knowledge
Shannon - 9 Jan 2008
Tell me Ishmael, when you buy your climbing gear, harnesses, draws, ropes and the like, do you buy ones that conform to a certain safety standard? Or do you grab any old rope from the hardware store or make a harness out of tape because you are a climber rather than part of the climbing community? No you buy the good gear because you know that this is an activity/sport/lifestyle which is potentially very dangerous and that when purchasing items to save your bacon you want them to be as good as can be, why should bolts be any different? Why should best practice not be used? Is it cos its cool and individual and defines who you are to use second rate protection?
ed nepia - 9 Jan 2008
Nope! checked my c.v, no entry under messiah. Just another climber who gives a sod
anyway give me a call if you have a job or perhaps we should just go climbing before we have to relive any old monty python sketches?
ed nepia - 9 Jan 2008
oh and maybe you could brush up on irony, a lots changed in 187 years
Ishmael - 9 Jan 2008
dunno about the climbing, your acolytes are a bit unruly. May see you at the Climbers Café . Toodel-loo
ed nepia - 9 Jan 2008
climbers cafe eh? So you are part of the climbing community after all.. but how will i know you Ishmael?
Or do you use another name amongst mortals?
The Life Of Brian - 9 Jan 2008
Ed is not the messiah he is just a naughty boy and Racheal should put him over his knee and spank him.
Ed you speak with the wisdom of a man of knowledge and experience. You not only care about your safety but the safety of others.
If you are looking for Ishmael maybe he is the dude with the rope bought off e-bay and he carries it in his portable petrol can. He is also likely to be seen wearing pink lycra pants with a matching gold necklace and Carabiner earrings.
The Life of Brian - 9 Jan 2008
Ed is not the messiah he is just a naughty boy and Racheal should put him over his knee and spank him.
that should read;
Ed is not the messiah he is just a naughty boy and Racheal should put him over her knee and spank him.
sorry for the spelling its hard to type whilst sitting in heaven. With all the angels trying to get me
Kurtz - 10 Jan 2008
"He cried in a whisper at some image, at some vision,-he cried out twice, a cry that was no more than a breath-'The horror! The horror!'"
The ambiguous dark motives of civilization and the freedom of barbarism shall be played out time and time again against one another. Public servants and outdoor educators would be well advised to take heed and be wary of the carrot enigma in such times.
As “Ride of the Valkyries” plays I think I see Marlow over my shoulder with a P-bolt and indemnity form.
Were-Rabbit - 10 Jan 2008
I can smell the carrots just waiting to be munched!
ed nepia - 10 Jan 2008
wow kurtz you and ishmael should write a book together
how about.. 'the heart of darkness is a carrot'
Kurtz - 10 Jan 2008
we already have.
its called the "lady bird book of climbing".
ed nepia - 10 Jan 2008
nice one, back soon with a witty non-de-plume
Were Rabbit - 10 Jan 2008
The Were Rabbit shall inflict frightful terror on the carrot brothers, muching their carrots starting with those on Carroterrorism when the moon is full.
Matt Rosser - 11 Jan 2008
The horror the horror
//www.youtube.com/profile?user=perthwiz
a wombat - 11 Jan 2008
nice one matt.
if you can't laugh you must be a politician, land manage or outdoor educator.
not sure i get the gingerbread men at the end though....
Ben - 6 Feb 2008
P, bolt, GIMB, cam, hex, nut, etc etc. I don't care what's in there. I check every piece of protection because that's the safe thing to do.
I just want to climb and I don't care what the FA puts in. If I'm too scared to use plates, I don't climb it. If I'm too scared or inexperienced to place trad pieces, I don't climb trad climbs.
If I want to climb it but find I'm deficient in the use of the protection on the climb, I go away and get better at it until I can come back and do the climb.
Why is it so hard and what happened to looking inside yourself to surmount the odds? I find it funny that some of those complaining about bolts are also the ones that will risk dangerous run-outs and other "less safe" practices..
I am my own control as to what is safe and unsafe.
Climb safe, climb smart and climb for you! :-)
George - 7 Feb 2008
...back in perth...arhh same gossop page.
What exactly is the argument about. Is it about the strength of the carrot?Is it the functionability your hating on?Is it Matt/Jim's obsessive chip-a-thon's of late?what the hell are you lads actually crapping on about. And why are people talking about pulling out bolts. Unless your joining us in rebolting established routes and contributing, then why the sudden outburst.
Me thinks you might actually be bringing more unwanted attention, from the wrong places than you realise.Not just climbers read these posts and they also don't fully understand the background to which all this had been done. So unless your going to actually put your names too your posts and have a genuine argument, then maybe cut back on the armchair bellowing.
g
Jeff M - 8 Feb 2008
George, this isn't a sudden outburst, this has been building for years, lots people do not want carrots, plenty of posts in the past, even Safer Cliffs Australia says they are unsuitable. CAWA has not/will not upgrade the bolting ethics, so something has to give. Carrots may have decent shear strength (though the fractured rock surrounding them may not) but they have pretty crap pull out strength, which in itself is a danger. I can choose when to place gear or run out a climb but can not really control how I will fall onto a carrot, I may drop straight down and it will be ok or I may be trying a move on the edge of my ability and fly off backwards, putting tension on a carrot and they are not made for that sort of loading. Also I have seen people post that climbers should pick and choose which climbs they climb and stay off carrot bolted routes if they do not like them. What happens if the first bolt is a fair way off the deck, you can't tell till you get too it and by then its too late. Locals may know about carrots but what about travellers? guide books do not state which climbs have carrots generally either.
George - 10 Feb 2008
Jeff
Firstly that should have read: "Sudden outburst AGAIN!!!!"
"CAWA has not/will not upgrade the bolting ethics, so something has to give"JM
What a ridiclous comment!. if you had read any of the bolting thread you would understand that the minority who are actually putting up routes have there own preferences and don't follow any set of ethics/guidelines.So what will change if CAWA changes what is written in the bolting ethics???. MAtt and Jim must be loving the fact that they have made you all so hot under the collar.
If you and this surposed majority don't like it so much, then go out there and DO SOMETHING ABOUT IT!!. Just pulling bolts out it PATHETIC AND LAME..if your going to do it, do it well and move on.
I would much rather discuse this over a beer after a hard days climbing..than be completely ball-less and go under a anonymous name..
Where is the love?? stop taking it so seriously and just CLIMB.
peace
Jeff M - 10 Feb 2008
Just out of curiosity, what are you saying here?
"If you and this surposed majority don't like it so much, then go out there and DO SOMETHING ABOUT IT!!. Just pulling bolts out it PATHETIC AND LAME..if your going to do it, do it well and move on. "
You say to do something about it but changing ethics is no good as M + J won't listen to them.
Then you say pulling bolts is pathetic and lame, though if we are going to do it, to do it well?
I would have no probs with M + J climbs if the glued in machine bolts, but they don't give a rats about the rest of us. So you tell me, what is to be done? You seem to have a problem with the carrots being pulled but do not really offer an alternative.
Climb somewhere else? Why sould people have to avoid new climbs simply because the first ascentionists were wankers?
If they only want to put up the climb to cater for themselves then they should have no probs with the carrots being removed after they have ticked it, better yet, If they are doin it for the community then it should be bolted properly in the first place.
George - 10 Feb 2008
Geez mate,call of the dogs
Ill spell it out: Just pull out the carrots and replace them with glued in machine bolts. I thought it would be an obvious choice, so no character is lost and you get your safe as houses bolts...seriously this is b/s.
Jeff M - 10 Feb 2008
Mate I can not call anyone off because I do not know who is doing it. I do however support whoever is pulling the carrots from new routes. There are better alternatives to carrots and it should be the first ascentionists, or sculptors if the routes are chipped placing decent pro in the first place. It does not have to be rings or fixe P's just glue in machine bolts and everyone happy and SAFE
assistant to were-rabbit - 10 Feb 2008
time to start munching all the carrots that the two wankers jim and matt have put in everywhere. all carrots will be munched so everyone is free to claim new routes